The Nature of Anger
Verbal Aggression
Physical/Financial Harm
Hidden Manifestations
Resentment and Revenge

1. The Nature and Core Concept of Anger (Ka'as)

This section provides a fundamental definition of anger and wrath; an intense, uncontrolled emotional reaction that can lead to a loss of rationality and destructive behaviors. In Judaism, anger is recognized as one of the most dangerous negative traits (Midot Ra'ot) and is the root of many other sins.


Anger/Wrath (Ka'as): The Destructive Fire of the Soul

כַּעַס (Ka'as) means anger or wrath. It is a powerful emotional response to dissatisfaction, frustration, or a feeling of threat. In Judaism, anger is recognized as one of the most serious negative traits that can quickly lead to greater sins and distance a person from HaShem and others. Jewish texts compare anger to idolatry, because in a moment of anger, a person seemingly forgets the presence of HaShem and surrenders control to their own base desires.

Why is this sin serious? How to overcome it:
  1. Recognize the Depth of the Sin: Deeply understand that anger is a great sin and pollutes your soul.
  2. Focus on HaShem's Greatness: Remember that HaShem is always present and observant, and that He controls everything.
  3. Practice Humility (עֲנָוָה): Accept that no one is perfect and that you also make mistakes. This helps reduce unreasonable expectations and anger.
  4. Pause Before Reacting: When you feel angry, pause for a few seconds, take a deep breath, and think before reacting.
  5. Change Physical State: Changing your body's position (e.g., sitting if you are standing) can help break the cycle of anger.
  6. Seek Support: Consult a rabbi or spiritual mentor and study Mussar texts.

2. Verbal Aggression and Intimidation

This category includes all forms of speech and verbal behavior expressed with the intent to harm, demean, threaten, or instill fear in others. These are direct and destructive manifestations of uncontrolled anger that disrespect human dignity and destroy relationships.


Shouting, Insulting, Threatening, and Intimidating (Tze'akah, Ni'uf Peh, Iyyum, Hatalat Eimah)

This section covers צְעָקָה (Tze'akah - shouting), נִאוּף פֶּה (Ni'uf Peh - using harsh/abusive words), אַיּוּם (Iyyum - threatening), and הַטָּלַת אֵימָה (Hatalat Eimah - instilling fear in others). These are various manifestations of anger expressed through verbal or intimidating behavior, aiming to harm, control, or demean another person. These actions cross the boundaries of respect and create an unsafe environment.

Why are these sins serious? How to overcome:
  1. Pause and Deep Breath: In moments of anger, pause and take a deep breath before reacting.
  2. Leave the Situation: If possible, remove yourself from the provoking situation or person to calm down.
  3. Use Soft and Calm Language: Consciously strive to speak in a calm voice and respectful tone, even when upset.
  4. Express Needs Constructively: Learn to express your needs and feelings calmly, respectfully, and assertively (without aggression).
  5. Practice Empathy: Try to understand the other person's perspective and feelings.
  6. Study Shmirat HaLashon (Guarding the Tongue): Understand the importance of controlling your speech and avoiding any negative talk.
  7. Professional Counseling: If these behaviors are uncontrolled, seek help from a mental health professional.

Shouting / Yelling

צְעָקָה וְהַרְעָשָׁה (Tze'akah VeHar'ashah - Shouting / Yelling): The Destructive Sound of Anger

Shouting or yelling refers to a state of expressing anger where an individual verbally attacks others with a loud, aggressive, and often harsh tone. Although this behavior may at first seem merely a strong emotional reaction, it is, in fact, an manifestation of כַּעַס (Ka'as - anger/wrath) that has gone unchecked and is directed at causing harm (primarily verbal) to another. In Judaism, this form of expressing anger is severely condemned and stems from a lack of מִדַּת הָעֲנָוָה (Midat Ha'Anavah - the trait of humility) and שליטה עצמית (Shlitah Atzmit - self-control).

Shouting violates the boundaries of mutual respect, destroys a safe environment, and can deeply wound the listener's soul. This behavior not only harms others but also damages the individual's own spirit and distances them from HaShem and others. In Jewish texts, anger and any excessive expression of it, including shouting, are linked to very negative traits and are even compared to idolatry, because in moments of anger and shouting, one seemingly forgets HaShem's presence and surrenders control to their egoistic desires.


Why is צְעָקָה וְהַרְעָשָׁה Problematic?

  1. Disrespect for צֶלֶם אֱלֹהִים (Tzelem Elokim - the Divine Image): Every human being is created in HaShem's image. Shouting at another person mars this Divine image within them and insults their dignity.
  2. Destruction of Relationships: Shouting and yelling dry up the roots of trust and respect, leading to fear, estrangement, and even the severing of familial, friendly, and social relationships.
  3. Root of Other Sins: Shouting is often accompanied by offensive words, lies, and לָשׁוֹן הָרַע (Lashon HaRa - evil speech), and can lead to more serious sins.
  4. Diminished Spiritual Stature: An individual who shouts becomes distant from HaShem. Wisdom departs from them, and their prayers are less accepted.
  5. Threat to Health: Chronic anger and shouting can lead to physical problems such as high blood pressure, heart issues, and psychological problems like anxiety and depression.
  6. חילול השם (Chilul HaShem - Desecration of HaShem's Name): Aggressive behavior and shouting by a religious person present a very negative image of Judaism and cause others to turn away from HaShem's path.

Related Sources:

  • תורה (Torah):

    • במדבר (Bamidbar - Numbers) 20:10-12 (Moses' Sin at Mei Merivah): As previously mentioned, Moses shouted at the Israelites in his anger and spoke to them with demeaning words ("הַמֹּרִים - O rebels"). This act caused him to lose the privilege of entering the Land of Israel. This event demonstrates the importance of controlling one's speech and anger, even for the greatest prophet.
    • דברים (Devarim - Deuteronomy) 23:10: "כִּי תֵצֵא מַחֲנֶה עַל אֹיְבֶיךָ וְנִשְׁמַרְתָּ מִכֹּל דָּבָר רָע׃" ("Ki tetze machaneh al oyvecha ve'nishmarta mi'kol davar ra.") - "When you go out as an encampment against your enemies, guard yourself from every evil thing." If even in wartime one must guard oneself from "evil things," then in normal circumstances, one must all the more so avoid shouting and anger.
  • תנ"ך (Tanakh - Nevi'im u'Ketuvim):

    • משלי (Mishlei - Proverbs) 15:1: "מַעֲנֶה רַּךְ יָשִׁיב חֵמָה וּדְבַר עֶצֶב יַעֲלֶה אָף׃" ("Ma'aneh rach yashiv chemah u'devar etzev ya'aleh af.") - "A soft answer turns away wrath, but a harsh word stirs up anger." This verse directly points to the power of gentle words in counteracting anger and the danger of harsh words (shouting).
    • משלי 15:18: "אִישׁ חֵמָה יְגָרֶה מָדוֹן וְאֶרֶךְ אַפַּיִם יַשְׁקִיט רִיב׃" ("Ish chemah yegareh madon ve'erech apayim yashkit riv.") - "A hot-tempered person stirs up strife, but one who is slow to anger calms a quarrel." Shouting ignites quarrels.
    • משלי 19:11: "שֵׂכֶל אָדָם הֶאֱרִיךְ אַפּוֹ וְתִפְאַרְתּוֹ עֲבֹר עַל פָּשַׁע׃" ("Sechel adam he'erich appo ve'tif'arto avor al pasha.") - "The discretion of a person makes him slow to anger, and his glory is to overlook a transgression."
    • תהלים (Tehilim - Psalms) 4:5: "רִגְזוּ וְאַל תֶּחֱטָאוּ אִמְרוּ בִלְבַבְכֶם עַל מִשְׁכַּבְכֶם וְדֹמּוּ סֶלָה׃" ("Rigzu ve'al techeta'u imru bilvavchem al mishkavchem ve'dommu selah.") - "Tremble, and do not sin; meditate in your heart on your bed, and be still. Selah." This verse permits internal anger but forbids its expression in a sinful way (like shouting).
  • מִשְׁנָה (Mishnah):

    • פרקי אבות (Pirkei Avot) 2:10 (Rabbi Eliezer): "כל הכועס – אם חכם הוא, חכמתו מסתלקת ממנו; אם נביא הוא, נבואתו מסתלקת ממנו." (As mentioned previously) - Shouting is a sign of lack of wisdom and control.
    • פרקי אבות 4:1: "איזהו גיבור? הכובש את יצרו." (Who is mighty? He who conquers his yetzer hara [evil inclination].) Shouting is a sign of surrendering to the yetzer hara of anger.
    • פרקי אבות 5:11: "ארבע מידות באדם... נוח לכעוס ונוח לרצות – רשע." (As mentioned previously) - Shouting, even if it quickly subsides, is a sign of a bad trait.
  • תַּלְמוּד (Talmud):

    • בבלי פסחים (Bavli Pesachim) 66b: "כל הכועס, כאילו עובד עבודה זרה." (Anyone who becomes angry, it is as if they worship idols.) This ruling, widely applied to anger and its expression (like shouting), indicates its profound repulsiveness.
    • בבלי נדרים (Bavli Nedarim) 22b: "כל אדם הכועס, אם חכם הוא, חכמתו מסתלקת ממנו... ואם עשיר הוא, עשרו מתמעט... אין הכעס שולט אלא באדם שפל." (Any person who becomes angry, if he is wise, his wisdom departs from him... and if he is wealthy, his wealth diminishes... Anger controls only the lowly person.) This statement shows that anger and shouting are incompatible with any positive virtue.
    • בבלי שבת (Bavli Shabbat) 105b: "הפורק כליו בשעת כעסו, חכמתו ניטלת ממנו." (One who throws off his garments in a moment of anger [a metaphor for irrational behavior], his wisdom is taken from him.) Shouting is also a type of loss of control and wisdom.
    • בבלי מגילה (Bavli Megillah) 27b: "אמר רב נחמן בר יצחק: לעולם אל ירגיל אדם את עצמו בכעס, דכתיב: 'כי כעס בחֵיק כסילים ינוח'." (Rabbi Nachman bar Yitzchak said: A person should never accustom himself to anger, as it is written: 'For anger rests in the bosom of fools.')
  • הלכה (Halakha):

    • רמב"ם (Rambam - Maimonides), משנה תורה (Mishneh Torah), הלכות דעות (Hilchot De'ot - Laws of Ethical Traits) 2:3: Rambam considers anger a "מידה רעה מאוד" (very bad trait) and advises individuals to strongly distance themselves from it. He specifically emphasizes avoiding harsh words and shouting. "וירחיק אדם עצמו מן הכעס עד שינהיג עצמו שלא יכעס כלל" (A person should distance himself from anger to the extent that he trains himself not to become angry at all).
    • שולחן ערוך (Shulchan Aruch), אורח חיים (Orach Chaim) 230:3: (As mentioned previously) emphasizes the necessity of controlling anger and not shouting, even during prayer.
  • מוסר (Mussar):

    • מסילת ישרים (Mesillat Yesharim): Ramchal considers anger one of the main obstacles to achieving קדושה (holiness). He emphasizes the importance of controlling speech and emotions to preserve the purity of the soul. Shouting mars this purity.
    • חובות הלבבות (Chovot HaLevavot): Rabbi Bachya ibn Pakuda emphasizes the importance of controlling one's tongue and avoiding all forms of verbal aggression, as these are signs of a lack of בטחון (trust in G-d) and קבלת הסובלנות (acceptance of forbearance).
    • "אורחות צדיקים" (Orchot Tzaddikim - Paths of the Righteous): This book dedicates an entire chapter to "הכעס" (anger) and considers shouting one of its worst manifestations. The book compares an angry person to a wild animal that has lost its reason and wisdom.
    • חاخام ישראל סלנטר (Rabbi Yisrael Salanter - Founder of the Mussar Movement): Emphasized that working on ethical traits, especially anger, requires continuous and internal effort. He believed that every word spoken in anger is lost and leaves nothing but evil in its wake.

Common Examples of צְעָקָה וְהַרְעָשָׁה:

  • At home:
    • Parents who shout at and humiliate their child for the slightest mistake.
    • Spouses who yell and use abusive language with each other during arguments.
    • An individual who reacts with anger and shouting to a small task or delay at home.
  • At work/in society:
    • A manager who yells at their employees and humiliates them in front of others.
    • An individual who angrily shouts protests at others in a queue or in traffic.
    • A teacher who shouts at their students, creating an atmosphere of fear and stress.
  • In public places:
    • Someone who yells loudly in a store or restaurant due to dissatisfaction.
    • Sports fans who shout abusive chants at the opposing team.

Ways to Overcome צְעָקָה וְהַרְעָשָׁה:

Overcoming shouting and yelling requires a conscious, continuous, and deep effort towards תיקון המידות (rectification of character traits), cultivating שליטה עצמית (self-control), אורך רוח (patience/long-suffering), and עֲנָוָה (humility).

  1. Understanding the Depth of the Sin and Its Consequences:
    • Understanding the Danger of Anger and Shouting: Deeply understand that shouting not only harms others but also spiritually distances you from HaShem and hinders your growth.
    • Reflecting on Harm to the Soul: Understand that anger and shouting pollute your soul and destroy inner peace.
    • Awareness of חילול השם: Recognize that your behavior presents a negative image of your faith.
    • Recalling the Analogy to Idolatry: Understand that in the moment of shouting, you have surrendered to your ego, not to HaShem.
  2. Strengthening יראת שמים (Awe of HaShem), אֱמוּנָה (Faith), and עֲנָוָה (Humility):
    • Focus on HaShem's Presence: Remember that HaShem is always present and observing. He hears every word that comes out of your mouth.
    • Practicing Humility (עֲנָוָה): Understand that no one is perfect, and you also make mistakes. This helps you to expect less from others or yourself and become less angry.
    • Seeing צֶלֶם אֱלֹהִים in Others: Everyone you shout at is created in HaShem's image. This thought can stop you from insulting them.
    • Gratitude (הַכָּרַת הַטּוֹב): Focusing on blessings instead of deficiencies helps reduce anger.
  3. Cultivating Positive Character Traits (תיקון המידות) and Practical Techniques:
    • Pause Before Reacting (הפסקה קצרה): This is the most crucial step. When you feel anger, pause for a few seconds.
      • Deep Breathing: Take several deep belly breaths.
      • Drink Water: Sip some cold water.
      • Count Backwards: Count down from 10 or 20.
    • Change Physical Posture (שינוי תנוחה): If you are standing, sit down; if you are sitting, stand up or leave the area. This physical change can also shift your mindset.
    • Leave the Situation (עזיבת המקום): If possible, step away from the provoking situation for a few minutes to calm down.
    • Calm Environment (סביבה רגועה): Keep your environment calm. Avoid annoying audio and visual stimuli.
    • Use Soft and Calm Language (דיבור רך ושקט): Consciously try to speak in a calm voice and respectful tone, even when upset.
    • Remind Yourself:
      • "השקט והבטח - Silence and Trust."
      • "זה יעבור - This too shall pass."
      • "מה שיוצא מהפה לא חוזר - What comes out of the mouth does not return."
      • "כעס זה עבודה זרה - Anger is idolatry."
    • Practice Compassion (חמלה): Try to think about the roots of others' anger or the reasons for their behavior.
    • Observing Shabbat (שמירת שבת) and Kashrut (כשרות): Observing Mitzvot can help you cultivate self-control and inner peace.
    • Exercise and Physical Activity: Exercise regularly. Physical activity can help manage stress and anger.
  4. Seeking Support and Guidance:
    • Consulting a רב (Rabbi) or מורה דרך (Spiritual Mentor): They can help you gain a deeper understanding of Jewish teachings on anger and practical strategies to overcome it.
    • Studying Mussar: Mussar texts specifically focus on cultivating humility, combating anger, and self-control. Regular study is highly beneficial.
    • תְּפִלָּה (Tefillah - Prayer): Ask HaShem for the strength and ability to control your tongue and overcome anger.
    • Psychological Counseling or Anger Management: If shouting has become a destructive and uncontrolled habit and is severely damaging your relationships, seeking help from a psychologist or therapist can be very beneficial.

Through continuous practice of these strategies, with strong will, and by relying on HaShem, one can overcome the destructive trait of צְעָקָה וְהַרְעָשָׁה (shouting/yelling) and live a life based on tranquility, patience, humility, and genuine connection with HaShem and others, which will benefit both the individual and society, materially and spiritually.

Using Harsh, Abusive, or Obscene Language

נִאוּף פֶּה / לָשׁוֹן רָעָה (Ni'uf Peh / Lashon Ra'ah - Using Harsh, Abusive, or Obscene Language): A Toxin in Speech

Using harsh, abusive, or obscene language refers to any hostile, demeaning, or vulgar speech expressed with the intent to harm, shame, or degrade another. This behavior is a direct and highly destructive manifestation of uncontrolled כַּעַס (Ka'as - anger/wrath). In Judaism, speech is recognized as one of the most powerful and dangerous tools, and its misuse for insults or curses is severely condemned. This act not only damages human relationships but also harms the speaker's soul and alienates them from HaShem.

Why is נִאוּף פֶּה / לָשׁוֹן רָעָה problematic?

  1. Violation of Disrespect for צֶלֶם אֱלֹהִים (Tzelem Elokim - Divine Image): Every human being is created in the image of HaShem. Verbal abuse of another harms this divine image and disrespects their dignity.
  2. לָשׁוֹן הָרַע (Lashon HaRa - Slander/Evil Speech): Using harsh and abusive words is often accompanied by לָשׁוֹן הָרַע (speaking negatively and falsely about others), which is one of the greatest sins in Judaism and can harm three people: the speaker, the listener, and the one being spoken about.
  3. Rooted in Anger and Arrogance: This behavior often stems from uncontrolled anger and arrogance (a feeling of superiority and a perceived right to insult others).
  4. Destroys Relationships: Harsh and abusive words dry up the roots of trust and respect, leading to fear, distance, and even the severing of family, friendly, and social relationships.
  5. חילול השם (Chilul HaShem - Desecration of HaShem's Name): Abusive and offensive behavior by a religious person presents a very negative image of Judaism and causes others to distance themselves from HaShem's path.
  6. Contamination of the Soul: Jewish texts emphasize that the tongue is the gateway to the soul. Ugly and offensive words contaminate the human soul and hinder spiritual growth.
  7. Irreversibility of the Word: A word is like an arrow released from a bow; once spoken, it cannot be taken back, and its destructive effects remain.

Related Sources:

  • תורה (Torah):

    • ויקרא (Vayikra - Leviticus) 19:16: "לֹא תֵלֵךְ רָכִיל בְּעַמֶּיךָ לֹא תַעֲמֹד עַל דַּם רֵעֶךָ אֲנִי יְהוָה׃" ("Lo telech rachil be'ammicha lo ta'amod al dam re'echa Ani HaShem.") - "You shall not go about as a talebearer among your people; nor shall you stand by the blood of your neighbor. I am HaShem." Talebearing (רכיל - Rachil) and slander (which includes insults) are serious sins of speech that can lead to "blood" and harm.
    • שמות (Shemot - Exodus) 22:27 (Punishment for insulting a ruler or judge): "אֱלֹהִים לֹא תְקַלֵּל וְנָשִׂיא בְעַמְּךָ לֹא תָאֹר׃" ("Elokim lo tekallel ve'nasi be'ammecha lo ta'or.") - "You shall not revile God, nor curse a ruler of your people." This verse refers not only to insulting HaShem but also to cursing authorities, indicating the importance of verbal respect.
    • במדבר (Bamidbar - Numbers) 12:10 (Miriam's punishment for speaking against Moses): Miriam was afflicted with צָרַעַת (tzara'at - a skin disease) for speaking against Moses, demonstrating the serious consequences of misusing speech.
  • תנ"ך (Tanakh - Nevi'im and Ketuvim):

    • משלי (Mishlei - Proverbs) 15:1: "מַעֲנֶה רַּךְ יָשִׁיב חֵמָה וּדְבַר עֶצֶב יַעֲלֶה אָף׃" ("Ma'aneh rach yashiv chemah u'devar etzev ya'aleh af.") - "A soft answer turns away wrath, but a harsh word stirs up anger." This verse clearly shows that harsh words ignite anger.
    • משלי 18:21: "מָוֶת וְחַיִּים בְּיַד לָשׁוֹן וְאֹהֲבֶיהָ יֹאכַל פִּרְיָהּ׃" ("Mavet ve'chayyim be'yad lashon ve'ohaveha yochal piryah.") - "Death and life are in the power of the tongue, and those who love it will eat its fruit." This verse emphasizes the immense and influential power of speech, which can be constructive or destructive.
    • משלי 12:18: "יֵשׁ בּוֹטֶה כְּמַדְקְרוֹת חֶרֶב וּלְשׁוֹן חֲכָמִים מַרְפֵּא׃" ("Yesh boteh ki'madkerot cherev u'leshon chachamim marpe.") - "There is one who speaks rashly like sword thrusts, but the tongue of the wise brings healing." This verse compares harsh words to sword wounds.
    • משלי 26:20: "בְּאֵין עֵצִים תִּכְבֶּה אֵשׁ וּבְאֵין נִרְגָּן יִשְׁתֹּק מָדוֹן׃" ("Be'ein etzim tichbeh esh u've'ein nirgan yishtok madon.") - "Where there is no wood, the fire goes out; and where there is no whisperer, contention ceases." Talebearing and harsh words are the fuel for the fire of contention.
  • מִשְׁנָה (Mishnah):

    • פרקי אבות (Pirkei Avot) 1:17 (Shimon Gamliel): "כל ימיי גדלתי בין החכמים, ולא מצאתי לגוף טוב משתיקה." ("Kol yamai gadalti bein ha'chachamim, ve'lo matzati la'guf tov mi'shtikah.") - "All my days I have grown up among the Sages, and I have found nothing better for the body [or soul] than silence." This Mishnah emphasizes the virtue of silence in the face of temptation to slander and insult.
    • פרקי אבות 2:10: "כל הכועס – אם חכם הוא, חכמתו מסתלקת ממנו..." (Whoever becomes angry, if he is wise, his wisdom departs from him...) - Loss of wisdom can lead to the use of harsh words.
  • תַּלְמוּד (Talmud):

    • בבלי ערכין (Bavli Arachin) 15b: This section extensively discusses the sin of לָשׁוֹן הָרַע (Lashon HaRa) and equates it with the sins of murder, idolatry, and adultery. Insults and curses are subcategories of לָשׁוֹן הָרַע.
    • בבלי נדרים (Bavli Nedarim) 22b: "כל אדם הכועס, כל מיני גיהינום שולטים בו." (Every person who becomes angry, all types of Gehenna (hell) dominate him.) Anger that leads to harsh words has very severe spiritual consequences.
    • בבלי שבת (Bavli Shabbat) 105b: "כל הכועס, אין יראת שמים שרויה עליו." (Whoever becomes angry, the fear of HaShem does not rest upon him.) A person who angrily uses harsh words is distant from HaShem.
  • הלכה (Halakha):

    • חפץ חיים (Chafetz Chaim - Rabbi Yisrael Meir Kagan), שמירת הלשון (Shmirat HaLashon - Guarding the Tongue): This book is the most important and comprehensive work on the laws related to speech. The Chafetz Chaim meticulously explains various linguistic sins, including לָשׁוֹן הָרַע (slander), רְכִילוּת (talebearing), אוֹנָאַת דְּבָרִים (verbal abuse), and וְקְלָלָה (cursing), and emphasizes the grave sin of using harsh and abusive words. He compares these sins to "עבודה זרה" (idolatry) and "שפיכות דמים" (bloodshed).
    • רמב"ם (Rambam - Maimonides), משנה תורה (Mishneh Torah), הלכות דעות (Hilchot De'ot - Laws of Ethical Traits) 2:3: Rambam considers anger a "מידה רעה מאוד" (very bad trait) and warns against it, as it is the root of many sins, including cursing and abusive speech.
    • שולחן ערוך (Shulchan Aruch), אורח חיים (Orach Chaim) 170: Emphasizes the importance of blessing HaShem and avoiding any ugly or abusive speech.
  • מוסר (Mussar):

    • מסילת ישרים (Mesillat Yesharim): Ramchal, in the chapters related to "זהירות" (Caution), "נקיות" (Purity), and especially "פרישות" (Separation/Asceticism), emphasizes the importance of controlling one's speech and avoiding any negative talk. He considers speech a powerful tool that can be used for holiness or for sin.
    • חובות הלבבות (Chovot HaLevavot): Rabbi Bachya ibn Pakuda, in "שער חשבון הנפש" (Gate of Soul-Accounting) and "שער התשובה" (Gate of Repentance), emphasizes the necessity of controlling speech and avoiding ugly words.
    • "אורחות צדיקים" (Orchot Tzaddikim - Paths of the Righteous): This book has extensive chapters on "הלשון" (the tongue) and specifically addresses sins of speech, including harsh and abusive words. It emphasizes the importance of "שתיקה" (silence) and "דיבור רך" (soft speech).
    • חاخام ישראל סלנטר (Rabbi Yisrael Salanter): Emphasized that working on ethical traits, especially control of speech, requires continuous and internal effort. He believed that speech reflects a person's inner state.

Common Examples of נִאוּף פֶּה / לָשׁוֹן רָעָה Manifestation:

  • At Home:
    • Shouting and using demeaning or abusive language towards a spouse or children due to a small mistake.
    • Insulting parents during a heated argument.
    • Using ugly or mocking nicknames for family members.
  • In the Workplace/Community:
    • Insulting colleagues, managers, or clients at work out of anger.
    • Cursing and swearing in traffic or public disputes.
    • Spreading rumors and slandering others with harsh and negative words.
    • Writing insulting and abusive comments on social media or online platforms.
  • In Education or Training:
    • A teacher who uses harsh and demeaning words with students.
    • A sports coach who insults their players with vulgar language.

Ways to Overcome נִאוּף פֶּה / לָשׁוֹן רָעָה:

Overcoming the use of harsh, abusive, or obscene language requires a conscious, continuous, and deep effort to engage in תיקון המידות (Tikkun HaMiddot - character refinement), cultivating שליטה עצמית (Shlitah Atzmit - self-control), אורך רוח (Orech Ruach - patience), עֲנָוָה (Anavah - humility), and שמירת הלשון (Shmirat HaLashon - guarding the tongue).

  1. Understanding the Depth of the Sin and Its Consequences:
    • Understanding the danger of spiritual destruction: Deeply understand that abusive and offensive words contaminate your soul and prevent closeness to HaShem and goodness.
    • Awareness of לָשׁוֹן הָרַע and חִלּוּל הַשֵּׁם: Recognize that these sins can harm three people and devalue HaShem's Name.
    • Remembering the irreversibility of the word: Understand that your words are like an arrow released; once spoken, they cannot be taken back, and their effects remain.
  2. Strengthening יראת שמים (Fear of HaShem), אֱמוּנָה (Faith), and וְעֲנָוָה (True Humility):
    • HaShem's Presence: Remember that HaShem is always present and observes, hearing every word that comes out of your mouth. This awareness can be a deterrent.
    • Seeing צֶלֶם אֱלֹהִים in others: Everyone you insult is created in HaShem's image. This thought can stop you from insulting.
    • Practicing Humility (עֲנָוָה): Anger and the use of harsh words often stem from arrogance and a sense of superiority. Humility helps you eradicate this feeling.
    • Trust (בִּטָּחוֹן): Trust in HaShem that He will establish justice, and you do not need to control others through harsh words.
  3. Cultivating Positive Ethical Traits (תיקון המידות) and Practical Techniques:
    • Practicing שמירת הלשון (Guarding the Tongue): This is a lifelong project. Consciously decide to weigh every word before speaking it.
      • Silence (שתיקה): In moments of anger, instead of reacting immediately, be silent.
      • Pause before reacting (הפסקה קצרה): When you feel angry, pause for a few seconds and think before reacting.
      • Deep breathing: Take a few deep abdominal breaths to calm yourself.
      • Physical change of state: Changing your body posture (e.g., sitting down if you are standing) can help break the cycle of anger.
      • Leaving the scene (עזיבת המקום): If possible, leave the place of conflict until the anger subsides.
    • Using soft and calm language (דיבור רך ושקט): Consciously strive to speak with a calm voice and respectful tone, even when upset.
    • Changing negative thoughts: Harsh words originate from negative thoughts. Try to direct your thoughts towards positive thinking (דָּן לְכַף זְכוּת).
    • Making amends and repentance (תיקון ותשובה): If you have harmed someone with your words, humbly apologize and strive to mend the relationship.
    • Daily study of Chafetz Chaim: Many religious Jews study portions of the "שמירת הלשון" daily to remind themselves of the importance of guarding their tongue.
    • Exercise and physical activity: Exercise regularly. Physical activity can help manage stress and anger.
  4. Seeking Support and Guidance:
    • Consulting a רב (Rabbi) or מורה דרך (Spiritual Mentor): They can help you gain a deeper understanding of Jewish teachings on guarding the tongue, anger, and לָשׁוֹן הָרַע.
    • Studying Mussar: Mussar texts specifically focus on cultivating self-control, humility, and combating anger and sins of speech.
    • תְּפִלָּה (Tefillah - Prayer): Ask HaShem for the strength and ability to control your tongue and speak good words.
    • Psychological counseling: If the use of harsh and abusive words has become a destructive and uncontrolled habit that severely damages your relationships, seeking professional help can be very beneficial.

Through continuous practice of these strategies, with strong will, and with reliance on HaShem, one can overcome the destructive trait of נִאוּף פֶּה / לָשׁוֹן רָעָה (using harsh, abusive, or obscene language) and live a life based on respect, peace, compassion, and true connection with HaShem and others, which will benefit both the individual and society, materially and spiritually.

Aggression (Verbal or Physical)

כַּעַס תּוֹקְפָנִי (Ka'as Tokfani - Aggression): The Destructive Fire of Anger

Aggression (verbal or physical) refers to any hostile and harmful behavior or speech expressed with the intent to harm another (through words, threats, or physical action). This behavior is a clear manifestation of כַּעַס (Ka'as - anger/wrath), but not merely anger; rather, it is uncontrolled anger that has escalated into negative action. In Judaism, anger is recognized as one of the most dangerous מידות רעות (Midot Ra'ot - negative traits) and the root of many other sins, with aggression being its practical and destructive manifestation.

Aggression can manifest in various ways:

  • Verbal Aggression: Includes insults, cursing, yelling, threats, mockery, sarcasm, and the use of demeaning language.
  • Physical Aggression: Includes hitting, pushing, property destruction, and any form of physical violence.

This trait not only harms others but also damages one's own soul and spirit, alienating the individual from HaShem and others. In Jewish texts, anger and aggression are likened to idolatry, as in a moment of anger, one seemingly forgets the presence of HaShem and loses self-control.


Why is כַּעַס תּוֹקְפָנִי Problematic?

  1. Root of Other Sins: Anger and aggression can lead to murder, assault, lying, insults, disrespecting parents, and many other transgressions.
  2. Destruction of Relationships: This behavior erodes trust and respect, leading to alienation in family, friendly, and social relationships.
  3. Disrespect to צֶלֶם אֱלֹהִים (Tzelem Elokim - The Divine Image): Every human is created in the image of HaShem. Aggression tarnishes this Divine image in oneself and others.
  4. Decrease in Spiritual Stature: An angry person becomes distant from HaShem, and their prayers and actions are less accepted.
  5. Threat to Health: Persistent anger and aggression can lead to physical and mental health problems.
  6. חילול השם (Chilul HaShem - Desecration of HaShem's Name): Aggressive behavior from a religious person presents a negative image of Judaism and causes others to distance themselves from the path of HaShem.

Relevant Sources:

  • תורה (Torah):

    • בראשית (Bereishit - Genesis) 4:5-7 (Story of Cain): "וַיִּחַר לְקַיִן מְאֹד וַיִּפְּלוּ פָּנָיו... וַיֹּאמֶר יְהוָה אֶל קַיִן לָמָּה חָרָה לָךְ וְלָמָּה נָפְלוּ פָנֶיךָ׃ הֲלוֹא אִם תֵּיטִיב שְׂאֵת וְאִם לֹא תֵיטִיב לַפֶּתַח חַטָּאת רֹבֵץ וְאֵלֶיךָ תְּשׁוּקָתוֹ וְאַתָּה תִּמְשָׁל בּוֹ׃" ("Va'yichar le'Kayin me'od va'yipelu fanav... Va'yomer HaShem el Kayin lammah charah lach ve'lammah naflu fanecha. Halo im teitiv se'et ve'im lo teitiv la'petach chatat rovetz ve'elecha tesukato ve'ata timshol bo.") - "And Cain was very wroth, and his countenance fell... And HaShem said unto Cain: 'Why art thou wroth? And why is thy countenance fallen? If thou doest well, shalt thou not be accepted? And if thou doest not well, sin coucheth at the door; and unto thee is its desire, but thou mayest rule over it.'" This verse describes anger as a sin lurking at the door that, if uncontrolled, can lead to tragedy (fratricide).
    • במדבר (Bamidbar - Numbers) 20:10-12 (Moses' Sin at Merivah Waters): "וַיֹּאמֶר לָהֶם שִׁמְעוּ נָא הַמֹּרִים הֲמִן הַסֶּלַע הַזֶּה נוֹצִיא לָכֶם מָיִם׃" ("Va'yomer lahem shim'u na ha'morim ha'min ha'sela ha'zeh notzi lachem mayim.") - "And he said unto them: 'Hear now, ye rebels; is it from this rock that we shall bring you forth water?'" Moses, due to anger, insulted the Israelites and struck the rock with his staff, and for this reason was not permitted to enter the Land of Israel. This demonstrates the serious consequences of even a צדיק (righteous person)'s anger.
  • תנ"ך (Tanakh - Nevi'im u'Ketuvim - Prophets and Writings):

    • משלי (Mishlei - Proverbs) 15:1: "מַעֲנֶה רַּךְ יָשִׁיב חֵמָה וּדְבַר עֶצֶב יַעֲלֶה אָף׃" ("Ma'aneh rach yashiv chemah u'devar etzev ya'aleh af.") - "A soft answer turneth away wrath; but a grievous word stirreth up anger." This verse emphasizes the importance of controlling one's tongue and avoiding verbal aggression.
    • משלי 14:29: "אֶרֶךְ אַפַּיִם רַב תְּבוּנָה וּקְצַר רוּחַ מֵרִים אִוֶּלֶת׃" ("Erech apayim rav tvunah u'ktzar ruach merim ivvelet.") - "He that is slow to anger is of great understanding; but he that is hasty of spirit exalteth folly."
    • משלי 16:32: "טוֹב אֶרֶךְ אַפַּיִם מִגִּבּוֹר וּמֹשֵׁל בְּרוּחוֹ מִלֹּכֵד עִיר׃" ("Tov erech apayim mi'gibbor u'moshel be'rucho mi'loched ir.") - "He that is slow to anger is better than the mighty; and he that ruleth his spirit than he that taketh a city." This verse considers self-control to be the greatest heroism.
    • קוהלת (Kohelet - Ecclesiastes) 7:9: "אַל תְּבַהֵל בְּרוּחֲךָ לִכְעוֹס כִּי כַעַס בְּחֵיק כְּסִילִים יָנוּחַ׃" ("Al tevahel be'ruchacha li'cheos ki cha'as be'cheik kesilim yanuach.") - "Be not hasty in thy spirit to be angry; for anger resteth in the bosom of fools."
  • מִשְׁנָה (Mishnah):

    • פרקי אבות (Pirkei Avot) 2:10: "הוא היה אומר: כל הכועס – אם חכם הוא, חכמתו מסתלקת ממנו; אם נביא הוא, נבואתו מסתלקת ממנו." (He [Rabbi Eliezer] used to say: Whoever gets angry – if he is a sage, his wisdom departs from him; if he is a prophet, his prophecy departs from him.) This Mishnah shows the loss of control and wisdom during anger.
    • פרקי אבות 4:1: "איזהו גיבור? הכובש את יצרו." (Who is mighty? He who conquers his Yetzer [evil inclination].) Anger is one of the most powerful Yetzer HaRa, which must be overcome.
    • פרקי אבות 5:11: "ארבע מידות באדם... נוח לכעוס ונוח לרצות – רשע." (There are four types of character in man... one who is easy to anger and easy to appease – he is wicked.) This indicates that even if anger subsides quickly, the angry disposition itself is negative.
  • תַּלְמוּד (Talmud):

    • בבלי פסחים (Bavli Pesachim) 66b: "כל הכועס, כאילו עובד עבודה זרה." (Anyone who gets angry, it is as if he worships idols.) This is one of the strongest statements about anger in the Talmud, indicating the depth of its severity. In a moment of anger, one seemingly forgets HaShem and worships oneself.
    • בבלי נדרים (Bavli Nedarim) 22b: "כל אדם הכועס, כל מיני גיהינום שולטים בו." (Any person who gets angry, all types of Gehinnom [hell] rule over him.)
    • בבלי שבת (Bavli Shabbat) 105b: The Talmud extensively discusses the harms of anger, including physical and psychological damage.
  • הלכה (Halakha):

    • רמב"ם (Rambam - Maimonides), משנה תורה (Mishneh Torah), הלכות דעות (Hilchot De'ot - Laws of Ethical Traits) 2:3: Rambam considers anger a "מידה רעה מאוד" (very bad trait) and advises a person to strongly distance themselves from it. He writes: "אדם שיש בו כעס, אין חייו חיים" (A person who has anger, their life is not life).
    • שולחן ערוך (Shulchan Aruch), אורח חיים (Orach Chaim) 230:3: Emphasizes the need to control anger and avoid shouting during prayer.
  • מוסר (Mussar):

    • מסילת ישרים (Mesillat Yesharim): Ramchal, in the chapters on "נקיות" (Nekiyot - Purity) and "פרישות" (P'rishut - Asceticism/Separation), addresses the dangers of anger and the necessity of self-control. He considers anger one of the main obstacles to achieving קדושה (holiness).
    • חובות הלבבות (Chovot HaLevavot): Rabbi Bachya ibn Pakuda, in "שער הכניעה" (Gate of Humility) and "שער התשובה" (Gate of Repentance), emphasizes the importance of humility and controlling negative traits, including anger.
    • "אורחות צדיקים" (Orchot Tzaddikim - Paths of the Righteous): This classic Mussar work specifically addresses the chapter on "הכעס" (Anger) and likens it to idolatry and Gehinnom. It offers practical strategies for overcoming anger.
    • חاخام ישראל סלנטר (Rabbi Yisrael Salanter - Founder of the Mussar Movement): He considered anger "אבי אבות הטומאה" (the father of all impurities) and emphasized the need for continuous effort to eradicate it.

Common Examples of כַּעַס תּוֹקְפָנִי Manifestations:

  • Verbal Aggression:
    • Yelling at a spouse or children for a minor mistake.
    • Insulting colleagues at work when angry.
    • Using vulgar or threatening language in road rage incidents.
    • Publicly mocking or demeaning others to assert superiority.
  • Physical Aggression:
    • Hitting children or a spouse in anger.
    • Breaking objects or throwing things when enraged.
    • Engaging in physical altercations with others during an argument or dispute.
    • Deliberately damaging others' property.

Ways to Overcome כַּעַס תּוֹקְפָנִי:

Overcoming anger and aggression requires conscious, continuous, and deep effort toward תיקון המידות (Tikkun HaMiddot - rectification of character traits) and the cultivation of סבלנות (Sablanut - patience), שקט נפשי (Sheket Nafshi - inner peace), and עֲנָוָה (Anavah - humility).

  1. Understanding the Depth of the Sin and its Consequences:
    • Grasping the Danger of Anger: Deeply understand that anger, in any form, is a grave and destructive sin that distances you from HaShem and others.
    • Reflecting on Harm to the Soul: Realize that anger pollutes your soul and hinders spiritual growth and inner peace.
    • Awareness of חילול השם: Recognize that your aggressive behavior presents a negative image of religion and causes others to distance themselves from HaShem's path.
    • Recalling the Analogy to Idolatry: Understand that anger, in that moment, distances you from HaShem and causes you to worship your own ego.
  2. Strengthening יראת שמים (Fear of HaShem), אֱמוּנָה (Faith), and עֲנָוָה (Humility):
    • Focusing on HaShem's Greatness: Remember that HaShem is always present and watching. Thinking of His presence can prevent anger.
    • Practicing Humility (עֲנָוָה): Understand that no one is perfect, and you also make mistakes. Accepting this reality reduces anger stemming from a sense of superiority or unrealistic expectations of yourself and others.
    • Seeing Good in Others (לדון לכף זכות): Try to interpret others' actions in the best possible light and give them the benefit of the doubt.
    • Gratitude (הַכָּרַת הַטּוֹב): Focusing on blessings and what you have, rather than deficiencies, helps reduce anger.
  3. Cultivating Positive Character Traits (תיקון המידות):
    • Deliberation in Speech and Action (התבוננות ומחשבה):
      • Pause Before Reacting (הפסקה קצרה): When you feel angry, pause for a few seconds and think before reacting. Take a deep breath.
      • Physical Change of State: Changing your physical posture (e.g., sitting down if you are standing) can help break the cycle of anger.
      • Leaving the Scene (עזיבת המקום): If possible, leave the place of conflict until the anger subsides.
      • Prayer and Torah Study (תפילה ולימוד תורה): In moments of anger, utter HaShem's Name or recall verses from the Torah.
    • Managing Triggering Situations (הימנעות מגירויים): Consciously avoid situations or people that typically trigger your anger, or enter them with preparation.
    • Changing Perspective (שינוי פרספקטיבה):
      • Asking Yourself "Whom Do I Serve?": Remind yourself that anger is a tool of the "יצר הרע" (Yetzer HaRa - evil inclination).
      • Visualizing Consequences: Imagine the harm your anger can cause.
      • Comparing to Great Sages: Remember how צדיקים (righteous individuals) overcame their anger.
    • Controlling Speech (שמירת הלשון): Specifically focus on controlling your speech. Even at the height of anger, avoid offensive and vulgar language.
    • Repairing Relationships (תיקון יחסים): If you have harmed someone due to anger, take the initiative to make amends and seek forgiveness.
  4. Seeking Support and Guidance:
    • Consulting a רב (Rabbi) or מורה דרך (Spiritual Mentor): They can help you deepen your understanding of Jewish teachings on anger and practical strategies for overcoming it.
    • Studying Mussar: Mussar texts specifically focus on cultivating humility, combating anger, and self-control. Regular study is highly beneficial.
    • תְּפִלָּה (Tefillah - Prayer): Ask HaShem for the strength and ability to overcome anger and cultivate inner peace.
    • Psychological Counseling: If your anger is disrupting your daily life or seriously damaging your relationships, seeking help from a psychologist or therapist can be very beneficial. Anger management is a learnable skill.

Through continuous practice of these strategies, with strong will, and by relying on HaShem, one can overcome the destructive trait of כַּעַס תּוֹקְפָנִי (aggression) and live a life based on peace, patience, humility, and genuine connection with HaShem and others, which will benefit both the individual and society, materially and spiritually.

Threatening

אַיּוּם (Iyyum - Threatening): A Destructive Tool Born of Anger

Threatening refers to any warning or expression of intent to cause harm (whether physical, financial, psychological, or social) to another, with the aim of frightening, controlling, or retaliating. This behavior is a strong and highly damaging manifestation of uncontrolled כַּעַס (Ka'as - anger/wrath). Although a threat may not result in actual harm, it is in itself a destructive and offensive act that can cause serious psychological damage to the threatened individual. In Judaism, threatening is severely condemned due to its roots in anger, arrogance, and the desire for control, as well as its potential to instill fear and inflict distress.

Why is אַיּוּם problematic?

  1. Rooted in Anger and Arrogance: Threatening often stems from anger and frustration, where an individual resorts to intimidation to gain control or express dissatisfaction. Arrogance also plays a role, as the one threatening perceives themselves as being in a position to punish another.
  2. Creates Fear and Anxiety: Threatening creates an environment of fear and insecurity. This can harm the mental well-being of the threatened individual and destroy relationships.
  3. Disrespect for צֶלֶם אֱלֹהִים (Tzelem Elokim - Divine Image): Threatening disrespects human dignity and free will, which are created in the image of HaShem.
  4. Destroys Relationships: Trust is the foundation of any relationship. Threatening destroys trust, leading to estrangement, hostility, and the severance of ties.
  5. חילול השם (Chilul HaShem - Desecration of HaShem's Name): Threatening behavior from a religious person presents a negative image of Judaism and causes others to distance themselves from HaShem's path.
  6. Potential for Violence: Threatening often precedes verbal or physical violence. When threatening words are used, ethical boundaries blur, and the likelihood of actual harm increases.
  7. Violation of דיני ממונות (Dinei Mamonot - Monetary Laws): In some cases, a threat can be considered a type of "אוֹנָאַת דְּבָרִים" (Ona'at Devarim - verbal/financial abuse), especially if its purpose is extortion or financial control.

Related Sources:

  • תורה (Torah):

    • ויקרא (Vayikra - Leviticus) 25:17: "וְלֹא תוֹנוּ אִישׁ אֶת עֲמִיתוֹ וְיָרֵאתָ מֵאֱלֹהֶיךָ כִּי אֲנִי יְהוָה אֱלֹהֵיכֶם׃" ("Ve'lo tonu ish et amitó ve'yarétta me'Elohecha ki Ani HaShem Elokechem.") - "You shall not wrong one another [through verbal/financial abuse], but you shall fear your G-d, for I am HaShem, your G-d." Threatening is a form of verbal wrongdoing that can lead to "אוֹנָאַת דְּבָרִים."
    • The most common implicit examples of threats in the Torah relate to the consequences of disobeying HaShem's commandments. HaShem warns the Children of Israel (which is effectively a Divine threat for behavioral correction), but these threats are for good and guidance, not out of uncontrolled anger. Human behavior that threatens out of anger contradicts this Divine pattern.
    • Story of Cain (Bereishit 4): Although Cain does not directly threaten, his anger and jealousy led to murder, rooted in the destructive potential of uncontrolled anger. Threatening is one of the initial stages before actual harm.
  • תנ"ך (Tanakh - Nevi'im and Ketuvim):

    • משלי (Mishlei - Proverbs) 15:18: "אִישׁ חֵמָה יְגָרֶה מָדוֹן וְאֶרֶךְ אַפַּיִם יַשְׁקִיט רִיב׃" ("Ish chemah yegareh madon ve'erech apayim yashkit riv.") - "A hot-tempered person stirs up strife, but one who is slow to anger calms contention." Threatening is a way of stirring up strife and tension.
    • Proverbs 29:22: "אִישׁ אַף יְגָרֶה מָדוֹן וּבַעַל חֵמָה רַב פֶּשַׁע׃" ("Ish af yegareh madon u'ba'al chemah rav pesha.") - "An angry person stirs up strife, and a furious person is full of transgression." Threatening is an example of "much transgression."
    • תהלים (Tehilim - Psalms) 37:8: "הֶרֶף מֵאַף וַעֲזֹב חֵמָה אַל תִּתְחַר אַךְ לְהָרֵעַ׃" ("Heraf me'af ve'azov chemah al tit'char ach le'hare'a.") - "Refrain from anger and forsake wrath; do not fret—it leads only to evil." This verse directly advises abandoning anger to prevent evil deeds, which include threatening.
  • מִשְׁנָה (Mishnah):

    • פרקי אבות (Pirkei Avot) 2:10: "כל הכועס – אם חכם הוא, חכמתו מסתלקת ממנו..." (Whoever is angry—if he is wise, his wisdom departs from him...) - Loss of wisdom and control due to anger can lead to threatening.
    • פרקי אבות 4:1: "איזהו גיבור? הכובש את יצרו." (Who is mighty? One who conquers their Yetzer HaRa [evil inclination].) The urge to threaten is one of the strongest Yetzer HaRas that must be subdued.
  • תַּלְמוּד (Talmud):

    • בבלי פסחים (Bavli Pesachim) 66b: "כל הכועס, כאילו עובד עבודה זרה." (Whoever is angry, it is as if they worship idolatry.) Threatening is the epitome of this self-idolatry.
    • בבלי בבא קמא (Bavli Bava Kamma) 92a (regarding "היזק ראיה" - visual damage): The Talmud even addresses psychological harm resulting from a hostile gaze or abusive speech. Threatening is far more severe than this.
    • The Talmud emphasizes the importance of "שלום בית" (Shalom Bayit - peace in the home) and "שלום בין אדם לחברו" (Shalom Bein Adam LeChavero - peace between a person and their fellow). Threatening violates both of these principles.
  • הלכה (Halakha):

    • חפץ חיים (Chafetz Chaim - Rabbi Yisrael Meir HaKohen), שמירת הלשון (Shmirat HaLashon - Guarding the Tongue): This work extensively discusses sins of speech. Although the specific word "threatening" is not discussed in detail, concepts like "לָשׁוֹן הָרַע" (slander), "אוֹנָאַת דְּבָרִים" (verbal abuse), and "הוֹצָאַת שֵׁם רַע" (defamation) include actions that threats can lead to. The Chafetz Chaim explicitly states that any speech that causes distress or harm to another is a sin.
    • רמב"ם (Rambam - Maimonides), משנה תורה (Mishneh Torah), הלכות דעות (Hilchot De'ot - Laws of Ethical Traits) 2:3: Rambam considers anger a "very bad measure" and warns against it, as it is the root of many sins, including hostile and threatening behaviors.
    • שולحان ערוך (Shulchan Aruch), חושן משפט (Choshen Mishpat - Financial and Legal Laws): These sections discuss laws related to harming property or life, as well as coercion and duress. Threatening is a form of coercion and creating an emergency situation, which is condemned legally and ethically.
  • מוסר (Mussar):

    • מסילת ישרים (Mesillat Yesharim): Ramchal, in the chapters on "נקיות" (Purity) and "פרישות" (Separation/Abstinence), emphasizes the importance of self-control and control of speech to prevent any word or action that causes harm or distress. He stresses the importance of "אהבת ישראל" (love of fellow Jews) and "אהבת הבריות" (love of all creatures), which stands in contrast to threatening.
    • חובות הלבבות (Chovot HaLevavot): Rabbi Bachya ibn Pakuda, in "שער הענווה" (Gate of Humility) and "שער הבטחון" (Gate of Trust), emphasizes the importance of submission to HaShem and avoiding the desire to control and humiliate others, which is the root of threatening.
    • "אורחות צדיקים" (Orchot Tzaddikim - Paths of the Righteous): This book has detailed chapters on "הכעס" (anger) and "הגאווה" (arrogance), specifically addressing the destructive consequences of these traits, including hostile and threatening behaviors.
    • חاخام ישראל סלנטר (Rabbi Yisrael Salanter): He considered anger "אבי אבות הטומאה" (the father of the fathers of impurity) and emphasized the necessity of continuous effort to uproot it. Threatening is one of the worst offspring of this impure father.

Common Examples of אַיּוּם Manifestations:

  • At Home:
    • Parents threatening their children with phrases like "If you don't do this, you'll never watch TV again" or "If you cry, you'll be punished."
    • A spouse threatening the other with separation, exposure, or financial harm.
  • In the Workplace:
    • A manager threatening an employee with dismissal, salary reduction, or defamation if their demands are not met.
    • A colleague threatening another with sabotaging their work or badmouthing them if they don't cooperate.
  • In Social Relationships:
    • Verbal threats in a street dispute (e.g., "I'll make you regret this" or "I'll hurt you").
    • Threatening to expose private information or ruin reputations on social media.
    • Blackmail or extortion with threats of harm.
  • In Legal/Business Matters:
    • Threatening to file a baseless or false lawsuit to pressure the other party.
    • Threatening to destroy property or assets if a debt is not paid.

Ways to Overcome אַיּוּם:

Overcoming threatening requires a conscious, continuous, and profound effort towards תיקון המידות (Tikun HaMiddot - rectification of character traits), cultivating שליטה עצמית (Shlitah Atzmit - self-control), אורך רוח (Orech Ruach - patience/long-suffering), עֲנָוָה (Anavah - humility), and חֶמְלָה (Chemlah - compassion).

  1. Recognizing the Depth of the Sin and its Consequences:
    • Understanding its Root in Anger and Lack of Control: Deeply understand that threatening is a sign of weakness and inability to control oneself, not power.
    • Reflecting on Harm to the Soul: Realize that this behavior contaminates your soul and prevents closeness to HaShem and inner peace.
    • Awareness of חִלּוּל הַשֵּׁם and Idolatry: Recognize that this act devalues HaShem's Name and religion, leading you to worship your own ego.
    • Understanding Legal and Social Consequences: Threatening can have serious legal repercussions and cause irreparable damage to your relationships.
  2. Strengthening יראת שמים (Fear of HaShem), אֱמוּנָה (Faith), and True עֲנָוָה (Humility):
    • HaShem's Presence and Judgment: Remember that HaShem is always present and watching, hearing every word that comes out of your mouth and judging everything.
    • Seeing צֶלֶם אֱלֹהִים in Others: Everyone you threaten is created in HaShem's image. Threatening is an insult to their Creator.
    • Practicing Humility (עֲנָוָה): Threatening stems from a sense of arrogance and a desire for control. Humility helps you eradicate this feeling and resort to dialogue instead of threats.
    • Trust (בִּטָּחוֹן): Trust in HaShem that He will bring about the best for you, and you do not need to use threats to achieve your desires.
  3. Cultivating Positive Character Traits (תיקון המידות) and Practical Techniques:
    • Anger Management (ניהול כעס): This is the most crucial step. Use anger management techniques:
      • Identify Triggers: Recognize your weaknesses and anger triggers.
      • Pause and Deep Breaths: When you feel anger or the urge to threaten, immediately pause and take several deep breaths.
      • Leave the Situation: If possible, remove yourself from the provoking situation.
      • Inner Calm: Increase your inner calm through exercise, meditation, and relaxing activities.
    • Constructive Expression of Needs and Feelings (ביטוי בונה): Instead of threatening, learn to express your needs, desires, and feelings in a calm, respectful, and assertive (non-aggressive) manner.
    • Practicing Empathy (אמפתיה): Try to understand the other person's perspective and feelings. Instead of reacting aggressively, consider what might have caused their behavior.
    • Problem Solving (פתרון בעיות): Instead of threatening to control a situation, seek practical and constructive solutions to problems.
    • Apology and Rectification (התנצלות ותיקון): If you have threatened someone, apologize to them and strive to repair the relationship.
    • Calm Environment (סביבה רגועה): Avoid environments and people who consistently provoke anger and the urge to threaten in you, as much as possible.
    • Reminder: HaShem is the Ultimate Ruler: Remind yourself that HaShem is in ultimate control, and you don't need to "force" others to your will.
  4. Seeking Support and Guidance:
    • Consultation with a רב (Rabbi) or מורה דרך (Spiritual Mentor): They can help you gain a deeper understanding of Jewish teachings on anger, self-control, and the importance of peace in relationships.
    • Mussar Study: Mussar texts specifically focus on cultivating humility, patience, and combating anger and the desire to control others.
    • תְּפִלָּה (Tefillah - Prayer): Ask HaShem to grant you the strength and ability to control anger and refrain from any form of threatening.
    • Psychological Counseling: If threatening has become a deep and uncontrolled behavioral pattern that seriously harms your relationships, seeking help from a psychologist or therapist for anger management and learning healthy communication skills is essential.

Through continuous practice of these strategies, with strong will, and with reliance on HaShem, one can overcome the destructive trait of אַיּוּם (threatening) and live a life based on respect, peace, trust, and genuine connection with HaShem and others, which will be beneficial both materially and spiritually for the individual and society.

Instilling Fear in Others

הַטָּלַת אֵימָה (Hatalat Eimah - Instilling Fear in Others): The Destructive Domination of Anger

Instilling fear in others refers to any behavior, speech, or action aimed at intimidating, terrifying, or dominating individuals by creating a sense of fear and insecurity. This behavior is a complex and deeply destructive manifestation of uncontrolled כַּעַס (Ka'as - anger/rage), accompanied by גַּאֲוָה (Ga'avah - arrogance/pride) and an intense desire for שליטה (Shlitah - control). An individual who instills fear in others through anger seeks to impose their will and suppress others' independence and human dignity. In Judaism, this behavior is considered not only a major ethical transgression but also a direct violation of the fundamental principles of respecting צֶלֶם אֱלֹהִים (Tzelem Elokim - the Divine Image) and establishing שלום (Shalom - peace) in society.

Why is הַטָּלַת אֵימָה problematic?

  1. Violation of צֶלֶם אֱלֹהִים: Every human being is created in the image of HaShem. Intimidation and instilling fear violate individual dignity and independence, disrespecting this Divine Image.
  2. Rooted in Anger, Pride, and Desire for Control: An individual who instills fear in others often suffers from inner anger and resorts to this behavior to vent it or to gain a sense of power. Pride also plays a crucial role, as the individual sees themselves as superior and entitled to dominate others.
  3. Destruction of Relationships and Society: Fear destroys trust. An environment governed by fear is unhealthy and hinders growth, cooperation, and flourishing. This behavior severely damages the fabric of society.
  4. Hindrance to תְּשׁוּבָה (Teshuvah - Repentance) and Growth: The individual who frightens another often prevents the intimidated person from speaking the truth or expressing grievances, which obstructs genuine repentance and rectification of wrongs.
  5. חילול השם (Chilul HaShem - Desecration of HaShem's Name): Nothing devalues HaShem's Name or presents a negative image of Judaism more than oppressive and intimidating behavior from a religious person.
  6. Seed of Violence: Instilling fear can be a stepping stone towards further physical or psychological violence.

Relevant Sources:

  • תורה (Torah):

    • ויקרא (Vayikra - Leviticus) 19:32: "מִפְּנֵי שֵׂיבָה תָּקוּם וְהָדַרְתָּ פְּנֵי זָקֵן וְיָרֵאתָ מֵאֱלֹהֶיךָ אֲנִי יְהוָה׃" ("Mi'penei seivah takum ve'hadarta penei zaken ve'yareta me'Elohecha Ani HaShem.") - "You shall rise before the gray-headed and honor the presence of an elder, and you shall fear your G-d. I am HaShem." This verse emphasizes the necessity of respecting others (especially elders), which is in complete contrast to instilling fear.
    • דברים (Devarim - Deuteronomy) 1:17 (regarding a judge): "לֹא תַכִּירוּ פָנִים בַּמִּשְׁפָּט כַּקָּטֹן כַּגָּדֹל תִּשְׁמָעוּן לֹא תָגוּרוּ מִפְּנֵי אִישׁ כִּי הַמִּשְׁפָּט לֵאלֹהִים הוּא..." ("Lo takkiru fanim ba'mishpat ka'katon ka'gadol tishma'un lo taguru mi'penei ish ki ha'mishpat le'Elohim hu...") - "You shall not show partiality in judgment; you shall hear the small and the great alike; you shall not be afraid of anyone's presence, for the judgment is G-d's..." This verse specifically emphasizes not instilling fear and not being afraid of others in a position of judgment.
    • References to the violence and oppression of Pharaoh and other oppressors: The story of Pharaoh, who enslaved the Israelites through oppression and fear, is an example of the abuse of power to instill fear, which led to divine anger and intervention.
  • תנ"ך (Tanakh - Nevi'im u'Ketuvim):

    • משלי (Mishlei - Proverbs) 29:25: "חֶרְדַּת אָדָם יִתֵּן מוֹקֵשׁ וּבוֹטֵחַ בַּיהוָה יְשֻׂגָּב׃" ("Cherdat adam yitten mokesh u'voteach ba'HaShem yesuggav.") - "The fear of man lays a snare, but whoever trusts in HaShem will be safe." This verse clearly points to the danger of humans instilling fear and the importance of trusting in HaShem.
    • משלי 15:18: "אִישׁ חֵמָה יְגָרֶה מָדוֹן וְאֶרֶךְ אַפַּיִם יַשְׁקִיט רִיב׃" ("Ish chemah yegareh madon ve'erech apayim yashkit riv.") - "A hot-tempered man stirs up strife, but he who is slow to anger quiets contention." Instilling fear is one way of stirring up strife.
    • Psalms 55:5: "לִבִּי יָחִיל בְּקִרְבִּי וְאֵימוֹת מָוֶת נָפְלוּ עָלָי׃" ("Libbi yachil be'kirbi ve'eimot mavet naflu alay.") - "My heart writhes within me; the terrors of death have fallen upon me." This verse describes the feeling of fear and dread that an individual who instills fear imposes on others.
    • Isaiah 2:11: "וְשַׁח גַּבְהוּת אָדָם וְשָׁפֵל רוּחַ אִישׁ וְנִשְׂגַּב יְהוָה לְבַדּוֹ בַּיּוֹם הַהוּא׃" ("Ve'shach gavhut adam ve'shafel ruach ish ve'nisgav HaShem levaddo ba'yom ha'hu.") - "The haughtiness of man shall be humbled, and the pride of men shall be brought low, and HaShem alone shall be exalted on that day." Pride, which leads to instilling fear, will ultimately be humbled.
  • מִשְׁנָה (Mishnah):

    • פרקי אבות (Pirkei Avot) 2:10: "כל הכועס – אם חכם הוא, חכמתו מסתלקת ממנו..." (Whoever becomes angry – if he is wise, his wisdom departs from him...) - The loss of wisdom and control due to anger can lead to intimidating behaviors.
    • פרקי אבות 4:18: "רַבִּי יַעֲקֹב אוֹמֵר: הָעוֹלָם הַזֶּה דּוֹמֶה לִפְרוֹזְדוֹר בִּפְנֵי הָעוֹלָם הַבָּא. הַתְקֵן עַצְמְךָ בַּפְּרוֹזְדוֹר כְּדֵי שֶׁתִּכָּנֵס לִטְרַקְלִין." (Rabbi Yaakov says: This world is like a corridor before the World to Come. Prepare yourself in the corridor so that you may enter the hall.) This Mishnah points to human responsibility in this world and the necessity of ethical behavior. Instilling fear prevents this preparation.
  • תַּלְמוּד (Talmud):

    • בבלי פסחים (Bavli Pesachim) 66b: "כל הכועס, כאילו עובד עבודה זרה." (Whoever becomes angry, it is as if he worships idolatry.) An individual who uses their anger to instill fear is, virtually, worshipping their own ego.
    • בבלי בבא קמא (Bavli Bava Kamma) 91b (regarding "היזק ראיה" - damage by sight): The Talmud even discusses the psychological harm caused by a hostile gaze or hurtful speech. Instilling fear is far more severe than this and inflicts more serious psychological damage.
    • בבלי תענית (Bavli Ta'anit) 20a (story of Rabbi Elazar ben Arach and Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai): In this story, Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai tells his students that he fears sins that desecrate HaShem's Name (חילול השם) more than the punishment for other sins. Instilling fear in others is an example of חילול השם.
    • The Talmud emphasizes the importance of "שלום" (peace) and "אהבת ישראל" (love of Jews). Instilling fear is in complete contradiction to these values.
  • הלכה (Halakha):

    • רמב"ם (Rambam - Maimonides), משנה תורה (Mishneh Torah), הלכות דעות (Hilchot De'ot - Laws of Ethical Traits) 2:3: Rambam considers anger a "very bad measure" (מידה רעה מאוד) and warns that it is the root of many sins, including hostile and intimidating behaviors.
    • חפץ חיים (Chafetz Chaim - Rabbi Yisrael Meir HaKohen), שמירת הלשון (Shmirat HaLashon - Guarding the Tongue): This book extensively discusses sins of speech and prohibits any speech that causes harm, shame, or psychological damage to another, including threats and intimidation. The Chafetz Chaim particularly emphasizes the sin of "הלבנת פנים" (shaming another in public), which is often associated with instilling fear.
    • שולחן ערוך (Shulchan Aruch), חושן משפט (Choshen Mishpat - Financial and Legal Laws): Generally, any action or word that causes "היזק" (damage) to another, even if not financial, is discussed. Instilling fear is a form of psychological damage.
  • מוסר (Mussar):

    • מסילת ישרים (Mesillat Yesharim): Ramchal, in the chapters on "הענווה" (Humility) and "פרישות" (Separation/Asceticism), emphasizes the necessity of self-control and avoiding the desire to dominate others. He considers instilling fear a sign of arrogance and a lack of understanding of HaShem's greatness.
    • חובות הלבבות (Chovot HaLevavot): Rabbi Bachya ibn Pakuda, in "שער הבטחון" (Gate of Trust) and "שער הכניעה" (Gate of Humility), emphasizes the importance of submission to HaShem and avoiding the desire to control and demean others, which is the root of instilling fear.
    • "אורחות צדיקים" (Orchot Tzaddikim - Paths of the Righteous): This book has detailed chapters on "הכעס" (Anger) and "הגאווה" (Pride) and specifically addresses the destructive consequences of these traits, including intimidating behaviors.
    • חاخام ישראל סלנטר (Rabbi Yisrael Salanter): He considered anger "אבי אבות הטומאה" (the father of the fathers of impurity) and emphasized the necessity of continuous effort to uproot it. Instilling fear is one of the worst manifestations of this uncontrolled anger. He also emphasized the importance of "רגש" (emotion) and "דמיון" (imagination) and believed that one must master these to avoid instilling fear in others.

Common Examples of הַטָּלַת אֵימָה Manifestations:

  • At Home:
    • A parent who severely frightens their children by yelling, threatening, or angry glares to elicit obedience, instead of explaining and teaching.
    • A spouse who keeps the other in fear through intense control, guilt-tripping, or threats of leaving the relationship.
  • In the Workplace:
    • A manager who forces employees to work harder through a harsh tone, constant warnings, and creating an atmosphere of fear, instead of motivating them.
    • A colleague who bullies, intimidates, or threatens sabotage to force others to do things.
  • In Social Relationships:
    • Bullies in school or social settings who physically or psychologically threaten, torment, and frighten others.
    • An individual who, in a discussion or dispute, intimidates the other party by raising their voice, getting physically close, or engaging in aggressive behaviors.
    • Using a position of power (financial, social, academic) to frighten and exploit others.
  • In the Digital Space:
    • Cyberbullying, where an individual intimidates another through frightening messages, images, or videos.

Ways to Overcome הַטָּלַת אֵימָה:

Overcoming the tendency to instill fear in others requires a conscious, continuous, and deep effort towards תיקון המידות (rectifying character traits), cultivating שליטה עצמית (Shlitah Atzmit - self-control), אורך רוח (Orech Ruach - patience), עֲנָוָה (Anavah - humility), חֶמְלָה (Chemlah - compassion), and אחריות (Achrayut - responsibility).

  1. Understanding the Depth of the Sin and Its Consequences:
    • Understanding the Root in Anger and Lack of Control: Deeply understand that instilling fear is a sign of inner weakness, pride, and an inability to manage anger in a healthy way.
    • Reflecting on the Damage to the Soul: Understand that this behavior contaminates your soul, distances you from HaShem, and prevents you from experiencing true peace and joy.
    • Awareness of חִלּוּל הַשֵּׁם and Violation of צֶלֶם אֱלֹהִים: Recognize that this act desecrates HaShem's Name and disrespects the dignity of human beings, who are created in His image.
    • Understanding Long-Term Consequences: Instilling fear destroys trust and irrevocably damages relationships.
  2. Strengthening יראת שמים (Fear of HaShem), אֱמוּנָה (Faith), and True עֲנָוָה (Humility):
    • HaShem's Presence and Absolute Power: Remind yourself that only HaShem has absolute power, and you do not need to intimidate others to achieve your desires.
    • Seeing צֶלֶם אֱלֹהִים in Every Person: Everyone, regardless of their status, is created in HaShem's image and deserves respect and dignity.
    • Practicing Humility (עֲנָוָה): Instilling fear stems from a sense of pride and a desire for control. Humility helps you eliminate this feeling and turn towards cooperation and respect instead of domination.
    • Trust (בִּטָּחוֹן): Trust in HaShem that He will arrange what is best for you, and you do not need to bully or frighten others.
  3. Cultivating Positive Character Traits (תיקון המידות) and Practical Techniques:
    • Anger Management (ניהול כעס): This is the most important step. Use anger management techniques:
      • Identify Triggers: Recognize your weaknesses and anger triggers.
      • Pause and Deep Breathing: When you feel anger or the urge to intimidate, immediately pause and take several deep breaths.
      • Leave the Situation: If possible, remove yourself from the provoking situation.
      • Inner Calm: Increase your inner peace through exercise, meditation, and calming activities.
    • Constructive Expression of Needs and Feelings (ביטוי בונה): Learn to express your needs, desires, and feelings in a calm, respectful, and assertive (without aggression or intimidation) manner. Use "I-statements."
    • Practicing Empathy (אמפתיה): Try to understand the other person's perspective and feelings. Instead of reacting aggressively, consider what caused their behavior and what effect frightening them will have.
    • Problem Solving (פתרון בעיות): Instead of using fear to control a situation, seek practical and constructive solutions to problems.
    • Apology and Rectification (התנצלות ותיקון): If you have frightened someone in the past, humbly apologize and strive to mend the relationship.
    • Cultivating Compassion and Kindness (חמלה וחסד): Consciously strive to treat others with kindness and compassion. These traits are in direct opposition to instilling fear.
    • Condemning Instilling Fear in Yourself and Others: Even if you cannot directly change, condemn this behavior in your mind and remind yourself that this is not HaShem's way.
  4. Seeking Support and Guidance:
    • Consulting a רב (Rabbi) or מורה דרך (Spiritual Mentor): They can help you gain a deeper understanding of Jewish teachings regarding anger, self-control, and the importance of peace and human dignity.
    • Studying Mussar: Mussar texts specifically focus on cultivating humility, patience, compassion, and combating anger and the desire to control others.
    • תְּפִלָּה (Tefillah - Prayer): Ask HaShem for the strength and ability to control anger and refrain from any intimidating behavior, and to fill your heart with kindness.
    • Psychological Counseling: If instilling fear in others has become a deep and uncontrolled behavioral pattern that seriously damages your relationships, seeking help from a psychologist or therapist for anger management, working on self-esteem, and learning healthy communication skills is essential.

Through continuous practice of these strategies, with strong will, and by relying on HaShem, one can overcome the destructive trait of הַטָּלַת אֵימָה (instilling fear in others) and live a life based on respect, peace, trust, cooperation, and a true connection with HaShem and others, which will benefit both the individual and society, materially and spiritually.

3. Physical and Financial Harm Resulting from Anger

This category addresses the most severe and destructive manifestation of anger: any physical act or destruction of property stemming from an uncontrolled outburst of rage. Such behaviors not only directly violate divine laws but also inflict harm on the lives, property, and well-being of others, severely devastating relationships and society.


Physical or Financial Harm (Hezek Gufani O Mamoni Mi'Ka'as)

הֶזֵק גּוּפָנִי אוֹ מָמוֹנִי מִכַּעַס (Hezek Gufani O Mamoni Mi'Ka'as) refers to causing physical or financial harm due to anger. This includes assault, destruction of property, and any physical or financial violence stemming from an uncontrolled outburst of rage. This is the most severe and destructive manifestation of anger, as it directly harms the life, property, or well-being of others and is considered a direct violation of laws pertaining to damages and human dignity in Judaism.

Why is this sin serious? Ways to Overcome:
  1. Anger Prevention: Identify your anger triggers and either avoid them or be prepared to confront them.
  2. In-the-Moment Anger Control Techniques: Pause and take deep breaths, leave the situation, wash your face with cold water.
  3. Restitution and Repentance: If you have harmed someone, make every effort to compensate for financial damages and seek forgiveness from the injured party.
  4. Commitment to Non-Repetition: Firmly decide never to repeat such an action.
  5. Practice Compassion and Empathy: By practicing seeing others with compassion and understanding their circumstances, you reduce the urge to cause harm.
  6. Professional Counseling: If your anger is uncontrollable and leads to harmful behaviors, seeking professional help is essential.

Aggression (Verbal or Physical)

כַּעַס תּוֹקְפָנִי (Ka'as Tokfani - Aggression): The Destructive Fire of Anger

Aggression (verbal or physical) refers to any hostile and harmful behavior or speech expressed with the intent to harm another (through words, threats, or physical action). This behavior is a clear manifestation of כַּעַס (Ka'as - anger/wrath), but not merely anger; rather, it is uncontrolled anger that has escalated into negative action. In Judaism, anger is considered one of the most dangerous מידות רעות (Midot Ra'ot - negative traits) and the root of many other sins, with aggression being its practical and destructive manifestation.

Aggression can manifest in various ways:

  • Verbal Aggression: Includes insults, cursing, yelling, threatening, mocking, sarcasm, and the use of demeaning language.
  • Physical Aggression: Includes hitting, pushing, destroying property, and any form of physical violence.

This trait not only harms others but also damages one's own soul and spirit, distancing them from HaShem and others. In Jewish texts, anger and aggression are likened to idolatry, because in a moment of anger, one seemingly forgets the presence of HaShem and loses self-control.


Why is כַּעַס תּוֹקְפָנִי problematic?

  1. Root of Other Sins: Anger and aggression can lead to murder, assault, lying, insults, disrespect towards parents, and many other sins.
  2. Destroys Relationships: This behavior erodes trust and respect, leading to separation in family, friendly, and social relationships.
  3. Disrespect for צֶלֶם אֱלֹהִים (Tzelem Elokim - Divine Image): Every human being is created in the image of HaShem. Aggression mars this divine image within oneself and others.
  4. Diminishes Spiritual Standing: An angry person becomes distant from HaShem, and their prayers and good deeds are less favorably received.
  5. Threat to Health: Chronic anger and aggression can lead to physical and psychological problems.
  6. חילול השם (Chilul HaShem - Desecration of HaShem's Name): Aggressive behavior from a religious person presents a negative image of Judaism and causes others to distance themselves from HaShem's path.

Related Sources:

  • תורה (Torah):

    • בראשית (Bereishit - Genesis) 4:5-7 (Story of Cain): "וַיִּחַר לְקַיִן מְאֹד וַיִּפְּלוּ פָּנָיו... וַיֹּאמֶר יְהוָה אֶל קַיִן לָמָּה חָרָה לָךְ וְלָמָּה נָפְלוּ פָנֶיךָ׃ הֲלוֹא אִם תֵּיטִיב שְׂאֵת וְאִם לֹא תֵיטִיב לַפֶּתַח חַטָּאת רֹבֵץ וְאֵלֶיךָ תְּשׁוּקָתוֹ וְאַתָּה תִּמְשָׁל בּוֹ׃" ("Va'yichar le'Kayin me'od va'yipelu fanav... Va'yomer HaShem el Kayin lammah charah lach ve'lammah naflu fanecha. Halo im teitiv se'et ve'im lo teitiv la'petach chatat rovetz ve'elecha tesukato ve'ata timshol bo.") - "And Cain was very wroth, and his countenance fell... And HaShem said unto Cain: 'Why art thou wroth? and why is thy countenance fallen? If thou doest well, shalt thou not be accepted? and if thou doest not well, sin coucheth at the door; and unto thee is its desire, but thou mayest rule over it.'" This verse describes anger as a sin lurking at the door, which, if uncontrolled, can lead to tragedy (fratricide).
    • במדבר (Bamidbar - Numbers) 20:10-12 (Moses' Sin at the Waters of Meribah): "וַיֹּאמֶר לָהֶם שִׁמְעוּ נָא הַמֹּרִים הֲמִן הַסֶּלַע הַזֶּה נוֹצִיא לָכֶם מָיִם׃" ("Va'yomer lahem shim'u na ha'morim ha'min ha'sela ha'zeh notzi lachem mayim.") - "And he said unto them: 'Hear now, ye rebels; is it from this rock that we shall bring you forth water?'" Moses insulted the Israelites due to anger and struck the rock with his staff, and for this reason, he was not permitted to enter the Land of Israel. This demonstrates the serious consequences of even a צדיק (righteous person)'s anger.
  • תנ"ך (Tanakh - Nevi'im u'Ketuvim - Prophets and Writings):

    • משלי (Mishlei - Proverbs) 15:1: "מַעֲנֶה רַּךְ יָשִׁיב חֵמָה וּדְבַר עֶצֶב יַעֲלֶה אָף׃" ("Ma'aneh rach yashiv chemah u'devar etzev ya'aleh af.") - "A soft answer turneth away wrath; but a grievous word stirreth up anger." This verse emphasizes the importance of controlling one's tongue and avoiding verbal aggression.
    • משלי 14:29: "אֶרֶךְ אַפַּיִם רַב תְּבוּנָה וּקְצַר רוּחַ מֵרִים אִוֶּלֶת׃" ("Erech apayim rav tvunah u'ktzar ruach merim ivvelet.") - "He that is slow to anger is of great understanding; but he that is hasty of spirit exalteth folly."
    • משלי 16:32: "טוֹב אֶרֶךְ אַפַּיִם מִגִּבּוֹר וּמֹשֵׁל בְּרוּחוֹ מִלֹּכֵד עִיר׃" ("Tov erech apayim mi'gibbor u'moshel be'rucho mi'loched ir.") - "He that is slow to anger is better than the mighty; and he that ruleth his spirit than he that taketh a city." This verse considers self-control to be the greatest heroism.
    • קוהלת (Kohelet - Ecclesiastes) 7:9: "אַל תְּבַהֵל בְּרוּחֲךָ לִכְעוֹס כִּי כַעַס בְּחֵיק כְּסִילִים יָנוּחַ׃" ("Al tevahel be'ruchacha li'cheos ki cha'as be'cheik kesilim yanuach.") - "Be not hasty in thy spirit to be angry; for anger resteth in the bosom of fools."
  • מִשְׁנָה (Mishnah):

    • פרקי אבות (Pirkei Avot) 2:10: "הוא היה אומר: כל הכועס – אם חכם הוא, חכמתו מסתלקת ממנו; אם נביא הוא, נבואתו מסתלקת ממנו." (He [Rabbi Eliezer] used to say: Anyone who becomes angry – if he is a wise man, his wisdom departs from him; if he is a prophet, his prophecy departs from him.) This Mishnah indicates the loss of control and wisdom during anger.
    • פרקי אבות 4:1: "איזהו גיבור? הכובש את יצרו." (Who is mighty? He who conquers his yetzer [evil inclination].) Anger is one of the most powerful yetzer hara that must be conquered.
    • פרקי אבות 5:11: "ארבע מידות באדם... נוח לכעוס ונוח לרצות – רשע." (There are four types of people... one who is easy to anger and easy to appease – he is wicked.) This indicates that even if anger quickly subsides, the angry disposition itself is bad.
  • תַּלְמוּד (Talmud):

    • בבלי פסחים (Bavli Pesachim) 66b: "כל הכועס, כאילו עובד עבודה זרה." (Anyone who becomes angry, it is as if he worships idols.) This is one of the strongest statements in the Talmud about anger, showing the depth of its vileness. In a moment of anger, one seemingly forgets HaShem and worships oneself.
    • בבלי נדרים (Bavli Nedarim) 22b: "כל אדם הכועס, כל מיני גיהינום שולטים בו." (Any person who becomes angry, all types of Gehinom [hell] rule over him.)
    • בבלי שבת (Bavli Shabbat) 105b: The Talmud extensively discusses the harms of anger, including physical and psychological damage.
  • הלכה (Halakha):

    • רמב"ם (Rambam - Maimonides), משנה תורה (Mishneh Torah), הלכות דעות (Hilchot De'ot - Laws of Ethical Traits) 2:3: Rambam considers anger a "מידה רעה מאוד" (very bad trait) and advises a person to strongly avoid it. He writes: "אדם שיש בו כעס, אין חייו חיים" (A person who has anger, his life is not life).
    • שולחן ערוך (Shulchan Aruch), אורח חיים (Orach Chaim) 230:3: Emphasizes the need to control anger and not to yell during prayer.
  • מוסר (Mussar):

    • מסילת ישרים (Mesillat Yesharim): Ramchal, in the chapters concerning "נקיות" (Nekiyot - Purity) and "פרישות" (P'rishut - Abstinence), discusses the dangers of anger and the necessity of self-control. He considers anger one of the main obstacles to reaching קדושה (holiness).
    • חובות הלבבות (Chovot HaLevavot): Rabbi Bachya ibn Pakuda, in "שער הכניעה" (Gate of Humility) and "שער התשובה" (Gate of Repentance), emphasizes the importance of humility and controlling negative traits, including anger.
    • "אורחות צדיקים" (Orchot Tzaddikim - Paths of the Righteous): This classic Mussar work specifically addresses the chapter on "הכעס" (Anger) and likens it to idolatry and Gehinom. This book provides practical strategies for overcoming anger.
    • חاخام ישראל סלנטר (Rabbi Yisrael Salanter - Founder of the Mussar Movement): He considered anger "אבי אבות הטומאה" (the father of the fathers of impurity) and emphasized the need for continuous effort to uproot it.

Common Examples of כַּעַס תּוֹקְפָנִי Manifestations:

  • Verbal Aggression:
    • Yelling at a spouse or children for a minor mistake.
    • Insulting colleagues at work when angry.
    • Using vulgar or threatening language in road rage incidents.
    • Publicly mocking or humiliating others to show superiority.
  • Physical Aggression:
    • Hitting children or a spouse when angry.
    • Breaking objects or throwing things when angry.
    • Engaging in physical altercations with others during an argument or dispute.
    • Intentionally damaging others' property.

Ways to Overcome כַּעַס תּוֹקְפָנִי:

Overcoming anger and aggression requires conscious, continuous, and deep effort for תיקון המידות (Tikun HaMiddot - rectifying character traits) and cultivating סבלנות (Sablanut - patience), שקט נפשי (Sheket Nafshi - inner peace), and עֲנָוָה (Anavah - humility).

  1. Understanding the Depth of the Sin and Its Consequences:
    • Understanding the Danger of Anger: Deeply understand that anger in any form is a great and destructive sin that distances you from HaShem and others.
    • Reflecting on Harm to the Soul: Understand that anger pollutes your soul and prevents spiritual growth and inner peace.
    • Awareness of Chilul HaShem: Recognize that your aggressive behavior presents a negative image of religion and causes others to distance themselves from HaShem's path.
    • Recalling the Idolatry Analogy: Understand that anger momentarily distracts you from HaShem and leads you to worship your own ego.
  2. Strengthening יראת שמים (Yirat Shamayim - Awe of HaShem), אֱמוּנָה (Emunah - Faith), and וְעֲנָוָה (Anavah - Humility):
    • Focus on HaShem's Greatness: Remember that HaShem is always present and observing. Thinking about His presence can prevent anger.
    • Practicing Humility (עֲנָוָה): Understand that no one is perfect and you also make mistakes. Accepting this reality reduces anger stemming from a sense of superiority or unrealistic expectations of yourself and others.
    • Seeing Good in Others (Ladon LeKaf Zechut): Try to interpret others' actions in the best possible light and give them the benefit of the doubt.
    • Gratitude (הַכָּרַת הַטּוֹב): Focusing on blessings and what you have, rather than on deficiencies, helps reduce anger.
  3. Cultivating Positive Character Traits (Tikun HaMiddot):
    • Deliberation in Speech and Action (Hitbonenut u'Machshavah - Contemplation and Thought):
      • Pause Before Reacting (Hafsakah Ketzara): When you feel angry, pause for a few seconds and think before reacting. Take a deep breath.
      • Physical Change of State: Changing your body posture (e.g., sitting if you are standing) can help break the cycle of anger.
      • Leaving the Scene (Azivat HaMakom): If possible, leave the scene of the conflict until the anger subsides.
      • Prayer and Torah Study (Tefillah u'Limud Torah): In moments of anger, utter HaShem's name or recall verses from the Torah.
    • Managing Triggering Situations (Himnanut mi'Giruyim): Consciously avoid or prepare yourself for situations or people that typically trigger your anger.
    • Changing Perspective (Shinui Perspektivah):
      • Asking Yourself, "Whom am I serving?": Remind yourself that anger is a tool of the "יצר הרע" (Yetzer Hara - Evil Inclination).
      • Visualizing Consequences: Imagine the harm your anger could cause.
      • Comparing with Great Individuals: Recall how Tzaddikim (righteous individuals) overcame their anger.
    • Controlling Your Tongue (Shmirat HaLashon): Specifically focus on controlling your speech. Even in the heat of anger, avoid insulting and vulgar language.
    • Repairing Relationships (Tikun Yahasim): If you have harmed someone due to anger, take the initiative to make amends and ask for forgiveness.
  4. Seeking Support and Guidance:
    • Consulting a הרב (Rav - Rabbi) or מורה דרך (Moreh Derech - Spiritual Guide): They can help you gain a deeper understanding of Jewish teachings on anger and practical strategies for overcoming it.
    • Studying Mussar: Mussar texts specifically focus on cultivating humility, combating anger, and self-control. Regular study is highly beneficial.
    • תְּפִלָּה (Tefillah - Prayer): Ask HaShem for the strength and ability to overcome anger and cultivate inner peace.
    • Psychological Counseling: If your anger is severe enough to disrupt your daily life or cause serious damage to your relationships, seeking help from a psychologist or therapist can be very beneficial. Anger management is a learnable skill.

Through continuous practice of these strategies, with strong will, and by relying on HaShem, one can overcome the destructive trait of כַּעַס תּוֹקְפָנִי (aggression) and live a life based on peace, patience, humility, and genuine connection with HaShem and others, which will benefit both the individual and society, materially and spiritually.

Physical or Financial Harm Caused by Anger

הֶזֵק גּוּפָנִי אוֹ מָמוֹנִי מִכַּעַס (Hezek Gufani O Mamoni Mi'Ka'as - Physical or Financial Harm from Anger): A Destructive Transgression

Physical or financial harm caused by anger refers to any physical act or destruction of property that stems from an uncontrolled outburst of כַּעַס (Ka'as - anger/wrath). This is the most severe and destructive manifestation of anger, as it directly harms the lives, property, or well-being of others. In Judaism, this behavior is considered not only a major ethical transgression but often a direct violation of laws related to נזיקין (Nezikin - damages) and צֶלֶם אֱלֹהִים (Tzelem Elokim - the Divine Image).

Why is physical or financial harm caused by anger problematic?

  1. Direct Violation of מצוות (Commandments): The Torah explicitly prohibits murder, assault, and destruction of property. Anger leads to the violation of these fundamental commandments.
  2. Disrespect for צֶלֶם אֱלֹהִים: Every human being is created in the image of HaShem. Physical harm to another is an insult to this Divine image. Destroying their property is also a form of disrespect towards them and HaShem.
  3. Rooted in Idolatry: As the Talmud states, "כל הכועס, כאילו עובד עבודה זרה" (Whoever gets angry, it is as if they are worshipping idols). In the moment of inflicting harm out of anger, a person forgets HaShem and worships their own angry self.
  4. Destruction of Society and Relationships: This behavior severely damages the fabric of society, destroys trust, and leads to separation, enmity, and endless conflicts.
  5. Diminished Spiritual Stature and Difficulty in Repentance: A person who causes physical or financial harm out of anger commits a great sin, and their repentance requires restitution for the damages and seeking forgiveness from the injured party.
  6. חִלּוּל הַשֵּׁם (Chilul HaShem - Desecration of HaShem's Name): Nothing devalues HaShem's name and presents a negative image of Judaism more than violence and destruction perpetrated by a religious individual.

Related Sources:

  • תורה (Torah):

    • בראשית (Bereishit - Genesis) 4:8 (Cain killing Abel): "וַיֹּאמֶר קַיִן אֶל הֶבֶל אָחִיו וַיְהִי בִּהְיוֹתָם בַּשָּׂדֶה וַיָּקָם קַיִן אֶל הֶבֶל אָחִיו וַיַּהַרְגֵהוּ׃" ("Va'yomer Kayin el Hevel achiv va'yehi bi'hyotam ba'sadeh va'yakom Kayin el Hevel achiv va'yahargehu.") - "And Cain spoke to Abel his brother; and when they were in the field, Cain rose up against Abel his brother and killed him." This is the first murder in human history, rooted in Cain's anger and jealousy. This event demonstrates the destructive potential of uncontrolled anger.
    • שמות (Shemot - Exodus) 21:12: "מַכֵּה אִישׁ וָמֵת מוֹת יוּמָת׃" ("Makkeh ish va'met mot yumat.") - "Whoever strikes a man so that he dies shall be surely put to death." This verse specifies the punishment for murder, and anger is often the primary cause of murder.
    • שמות 21:18-19 (Laws concerning physical harm): "וְכִי יְרִיבֻן אֲנָשִׁים וְהִכָּה אִישׁ אֶת רֵעֵהוּ בְּאֶבֶן אוֹ בְּאֶגְרֹף וְלֹא יָמוּת וְנָפַל לְמִשְׁכָּב׃ אִם יָקוּם וְהִתְהַלֵּךְ בַּחוּץ עַל מִשְׁעַנְתּוֹ וְנִקָּה הַמַּכֶּה רַק שִׁבְתּוֹ יִתֵּן וְרַפֹּא1 יְרַפֵּא׃" ("Ve'chi yerivun anashim ve'hikkah ish et re'ehu be'even o be'egrof ve'lo yamut ve'nafal le'mishkav. Im yakum ve'hithallech ba'chutz al mish'anto ve'nikkah ha'makkeh rak shivto yiten ve'rappo yerappeh.") - "And if men contend, and one strikes the other with a stone or with a fist, and he does not die but takes to his bed; if he rises again and walks abroad with his staff, then he who struck him shall be cleared [of death penalty], but he shall pay for the loss of his time, and shall have him thoroughly healed." These verses emphasize the necessity of compensation for physical injuries resulting from anger or disputes.
    • שמות 22:4-5 (Laws concerning financial damage): "כִּי יַבְעֶר אִישׁ שָׂדֶה אוֹ כֶרֶם וְשִׁלַּח אֶת בְּעִירוֹ וּבִעֵר בִּשְׂדֵה אַחֵר מֵיטַב שָׂדֵהוּ וּמֵיטַב כַּרְמוֹ יְשַׁלֵּם׃" ("Ki yav'er ish sadeh o cherem ve'shillach et be'iro u'vi'er bi'sdeh acher meitav sadehu u'meitav karmo yeshallem.") - "If a man causes a field or vineyard to be eaten, and lets his beast loose, and it feeds in another man's field, he shall make restitution from the best of his own field and the best of his own vineyard." These verses emphasize the necessity of compensating for financial damages, even if indirect. If such harm stems from anger, the burden of sin is greater.
  • תנ"ך (Tanakh - Nevi'im u'Ketuvim):

    • משלי (Mishlei - Proverbs) 15:18: "אִישׁ חֵמָה יְגָרֶה מָדוֹן וְאֶרֶךְ אַפַּיִם יַשְׁקִיט רִיב׃" ("Ish chemah yegareh madon ve'erech apayim yashkit riv.") - "A hot-tempered man stirs up strife, but he who is slow to anger quiets contention." This verse clearly shows that anger is the main cause of strife and harm.
    • משלי 29:22: "אִישׁ אַף יְגָרֶה מָדוֹן וּבַעַל חֵמָה רַב פֶּשַׁע׃" ("Ish af yegareh madon u'ba'al chemah rav pesha.") - "An angry man stirs up strife, and a furious man abounds in transgression." This verse connects anger with being "abounding in transgression."
    • איוב (Iyov - Job) 5:2: "כִּי לֶאֱוִיל יַהֲרֹג כָּעַשׂ וְכִסִיל תַּהֲרֹג קִנְאָה׃" ("Ki le'evvil yaharog ka'as ve'k'sil taharog kin'ah.") - "For anger slays the foolish man, and jealousy kills the simple man." (This verse can also be interpreted metaphorically as "destroying".)
  • מִשְׁנָה (Mishnah):

    • מסכת בבא קמא (Masechet Bava Kamma): This Talmudic tractate fully addresses the laws related to "Nezikin" (damages), describing various types of physical and financial harm and how to compensate for them. These laws are based on the Jewish ethical principles of not harming others.
    • פרקי אבות (Pirkei Avot) 2:10: "כל הכועס – אם חכם הוא, חכמתו מסתלקת ממנו..." (Whoever becomes angry – if he is wise, his wisdom departs from him...) - Loss of wisdom and control can lead to physical and financial harm.
  • תַּלְמוּד (Talmud):

    • בבלי פסחים (Bavli Pesachim) 66b: "כל הכועס, כאילו עובד עבודה זרה." (Whoever gets angry, it is as if he is worshipping idols.) This ruling, which specifically applies to anger leading to physical or financial harm, demonstrates the depth of this sin's severity.
    • בבלי נדרים (Bavli Nedarim) 22b: "כל אדם הכועס, כל מיני גיהינום שולטים בו." (Any person who gets angry, all types of Gehinnom [hell] rule over him.) This refers to the spiritual consequences of anger that can lead to harmful actions.
    • בבלי בבא קמא (Bavli Bava Kamma) 91b: It explicitly states that "אדם מועד לעולם" (a person is always forewarned [responsible for the harm they cause]). This means that even if the harm is caused by anger and lack of control, the person is still responsible for making restitution.
    • The Talmud discusses the importance of "דיני נפשות" (Dinei Nefashot - laws concerning life/murder) and "דיני ממונות" (Dinei Mamonot - financial laws), which are highly relevant to physical and financial harm.
  • הלכה (Halakha):

    • רמב"ם (Rambam - Maimonides), משנה תורה (Mishneh Torah), הלכות חובל ומזיק (Hilchot Chovel U'Mazik - Laws Concerning One Who Injures and Damages): Rambam elaborates in these sections on various types of physical and financial harm and the obligations of the aggressor to compensate for the damage. He emphasizes that even if the harm is due to anger or is unintentional, the responsibility for restitution remains.
    • רמב"ם, הלכות דעות (Hilchot De'ot - Laws of Character Traits) 2:3: Rambam considers anger "מידה רעה מאוד" (a very bad trait) and warns against it, as it is the root of many sins, including causing harm.
  • מוסר (Mussar):

    • מסילת ישרים (Mesillat Yesharim): Ramchal considers anger one of the greatest obstacles to achieving Kedushah (holiness) and piety. He warns that anger causes a person to lose control and leads them towards evil acts.
    • חובות הלבבות (Chovot HaLevavot): Rabbi Bachya ibn Pakuda, in "שער חשבון הנפש" (Gate of Soul Accounting) and "שער התשובה" (Gate of Repentance), emphasizes the importance of controlling emotions and understanding the roots of anger to prevent the occurrence of harm.
    • "אורחות צדיקים" (Orchot Tzaddikim - Paths of the Righteous): This book dedicates an entire chapter to "הכעס" (anger), likening it to idolatry and Gehinnom. It specifically addresses the destructive consequences of anger, including physical and financial harm.
    • חاخام ישראל סלנטר (Rabbi Yisrael Salanter - founder of the Mussar movement): He considered anger "אבי אבות הטומאה" (the father of the fathers of impurity) and emphasized the necessity of continuous effort to eradicate it, as it can lead to wicked actions.

Common Examples of הֶזֵק גּוּפָנִי אוֹ מָמוֹנִי מִכַּעַס:

  • Physical Harm:
    • Assaulting a child or spouse in a fit of rage and anger.
    • Engaging in a physical altercation with someone during an argument or dispute that leads to injury.
    • Throwing an object at someone and causing them harm.
    • Traffic accidents caused by aggressive and angry driving that result in injury or death.
  • Financial Harm:
    • Intentionally breaking household items or another person's property in a moment of anger.
    • Tearing up someone's important documents or papers out of anger.
    • Vandalizing public or private property (such as cars, shop windows) during a protest or riot fueled by anger.
    • Deliberately setting property on fire due to anger or resentment.
    • Intentionally disinheriting an heir out of anger and revenge.

Ways to Overcome הֶזֵק גּוּפָנִי אוֹ מָמוֹנִי מִכַּעַס:

Overcoming this destructive trait requires conscious, continuous, and deep effort towards תיקון המידות (Tikun HaMiddot - rectifying character traits) and cultivating שליטה עצמית (Shlitah Atzmit - self-control), אורך רוח (Orech Ruach - patience/long-suffering), עֲנָוָה (Anavah - humility), and חֶמְלָה (Chemlah - compassion).

  1. Understanding the Depth of the Sin and its Consequences:
    • Understanding the Risk to Life and Property: Deeply internalize that physical or financial harm is among the greatest sins between a person and their fellow human being (בין אדם לחברו - Bein Adam LeChavero).
    • Reflecting on Harm to the Soul: Understand that this action pollutes your soul and prevents you from experiencing inner peace and closeness to HaShem.
    • Awareness of חִלּוּל הַשֵּׁם and Idolatry: Recognize that this behavior devalues HaShem's name and religion, and leads you to worship your own ego.
    • Awareness of Legal and Ethical Responsibilities: Understand that you are responsible for the damages caused and must make restitution.
  2. Strengthening יראת שמים (Fear of HaShem), אֱמוּנָה (Faith), and True עֲנָוָה (Humility):
    • Focus on HaShem's Greatness and His Law: Remember that HaShem has established clear laws for human relationships, and He is watching over your actions.
    • Seeing צֶלֶם אֱלֹהִים in Others: Every human being is created in HaShem's image. Harming another is an insult to their Creator.
    • Practicing Humility (עֲנָוָה): Anger and the desire to cause harm often stem from pride and the belief that you have the right to "punish" another. Humility helps you eliminate this feeling.
    • Trust (בִּטָּחוֹן - Bitachon): Trust in HaShem that He will establish justice, and you do not need to administer justice yourself, especially out of anger.
  3. Cultivating Positive Character Traits (תיקון המידות) and Practical Techniques:
    • Anger Prevention (מניעת כעס):
      • Identify Triggers: Recognize your weaknesses and anger triggers, and either avoid them or prepare to deal with them.
      • Stress Management: Stress can increase anger. Manage your stress through exercise, adequate rest, and calming activities.
      • Change Environment: If an environment or individuals consistently anger you, make changes if possible.
    • On-the-Spot Anger Control Techniques (שליטה ברגע - Shelitah Ba'Rega):
      • Pause and Deep Breathing: When you feel angry, immediately pause. Take several deep belly breaths.
      • Leave the Scene (עזיבת המקום - Azivat HaMakom): If possible, distance yourself from the provoking situation or person until the anger subsides.
      • Cold Water: Wash your face with cold water or drink cold water.
      • Change Physical State: If standing, sit down; if sitting, stand up.
      • Think of HaShem: Utter HaShem's name or think about His presence.
    • Restitution and Repentance (תיקון ותשובה - Tikun u'Teshuvah):
      • Compensation for Damages: If you have caused physical or financial harm to someone, you must make every effort to compensate for the financial damage and also seek forgiveness from the injured party. Repentance is not complete without restitution.
      • Commitment to Non-Recurrence: For true repentance, you must firmly resolve never to repeat such an action.
      • Self-Examination (חשבון נפש - Cheshbon HaNefesh): Regularly look within yourself to find the roots of anger and work on them.
    • Compassion and Empathy (חמלה ואמפתיה - Chemlah v'Empathia): By practicing seeing others with compassion and understanding their circumstances, you can reduce the urge to cause harm.
  4. Seeking Support and Guidance:
    • Consult with a רב (Rabbi) or מורה דרך (Moreh Derech - spiritual guide): They can help you deepen your understanding of Jewish teachings on anger, repentance, and restitution.
    • Mussar Study: Mussar texts specifically focus on cultivating self-control, humility, and combating anger.
    • תְּפִלָּה (Tefillah - Prayer): Ask HaShem for the strength and ability to control anger and refrain from causing any harm.
    • Professional Counseling: If your anger is uncontrollable and leads to harmful behaviors, seeking help from a psychologist or therapist for anger management is essential.

Through continuous practice of these strategies, with strong will, and by relying on HaShem, one can overcome the destructive trait of הֶזֵק גּוּפָנִי אוֹ מָמוֹנִי מִכַּעַס (physical or financial harm caused by anger) and live a life based on respect, justice, compassion, and true connection with HaShem and others, which will benefit both the individual and society, materially and spiritually.

4. Hidden and Rooted Manifestations of Anger

This category includes traits and behaviors that may not appear directly aggressive but are rooted in uncontrolled anger, pride, and lack of trust. These can manifest as impatience, stubbornness, hasty judgments, chronic bad temper, or sharp reactions to criticism, hindering personal growth and healthy relationships.


Impatience, Obstinacy, Hasty Judgment, Bad Temper, and Reaction to Criticism

This section includes חֹסֶר סַבְלָנוּת (Choser Savlanut - Impatience), עַקְשָׁנוּת / סָרְבָנוּת (Akshanut / Sarvanut - Obstinacy/Stubbornness), שִׁפּוּט חָפוּז (Shiput Chafuz - Hasty Judgment), רֹעַ לֵב / קַפְּדָנוּת (Ro'a Lev / Kapdanut - Bad Temper/Ill-temper), and יְצִיאָה מִשְׁלִיטָה בִּשְׁעַת בִּקֹּרֶת (Yetzia Mi'Shlitah Bi'She'at Bikoret - Losing control during criticism). While these traits may not be directly violent, they are all rooted in anger, pride, and a lack of self-control, hindering spiritual growth and healthy relationships.

Why are these sins serious? Path to Overcoming:
  1. Self-Awareness and Introspection: Identify the triggers and roots of these traits within yourself.
  2. Practicing Patience and Forbearance (אורך רוח - Orech Ruach): Consciously practice patience in small situations.
  3. Acceptance of Mistakes and Flexibility: Accept that you might be wrong and be ready to change your mind.
  4. Judging Favorably (דָּן לְכַף זְכוּת - Dan L'chaf Zechut): Always assume the best possible intention for others' actions.
  5. Active Listening to Criticism: Instead of reacting immediately, listen to criticism with an open mind and try to learn from it.
  6. Cultivating Joy and Gratitude: Focus on blessings and positive aspects of life.
  7. Counseling: If these traits are deep-seated and chronic, seek help from a professional.

Impatience

חֹסֶר סַבְלָנוּת (Choser Savlanut - Impatience): A Hidden Root of Anger

Impatience refers to a psychological and behavioral state where an individual lacks the ability to tolerate delay, difficulty, or waiting, and quickly loses control or becomes anxious. This trait, though not directly aggressive, is closely linked to כַּעַס (Ka'as - Anger/Wrath) and often manifests as one of its earliest signs. Impatience subtly stems from unrealistic expectations, self-centeredness, and a lack of בִּטָּחוֹן (Bitachon - Trust/Reliance) in HaShem.

Why is impatience linked to anger?

  • Expectations: An impatient person often expects everything to happen immediately and according to their wishes. When these expectations are not met, disappointment, and then anger, arise.
  • Self-centeredness: Impatience is a form of excessive focus on "me" and "my needs." This self-centeredness contradicts consideration for others and acceptance of Divine will.
  • Lack of Trust: An impatient person often lacks complete trust in HaShem. They want to see results immediately and do not trust HaShem's wisdom and timing.
  • Hidden Anxiety: Impatience can be a sign of hidden anxiety that erupts as anger at the slightest delay or challenge.
  • Need for Control: Impatience is related to the need to control situations and people. When control is lost, anger appears.

In Judaism, the trait of אורך רוח (Orech Ruach - Long-suffering/Forbearance) and סבלנות (Savlanut - Patience) is strongly emphasized and is also recognized as a characteristic of HaShem. Conversely, impatience is a sign of spiritual and emotional weakness that can lead to other transgressions such as yelling, gossip (לָשׁוֹן הָרַע - Lashon HaRa), hasty judgment, and despair (ייאוש - Ye'ush).


Why is חֹסֶר סַבְלָנוּת problematic?

  1. Root of Anger and Other Transgressions: Impatience can quickly lead to anger, verbal aggression, and rash decisions.
  2. Destroys Relationships: Human relationships are built on respect, mutual understanding, and patience. Impatience can disrupt these relationships.
  3. Hindrance to Spiritual Growth: Many מצוות (commandments) and life's trials require patience. Impatience prevents their performance with pure intention.
  4. Lack of Trust in HaShem: Impatience indicates a lack of trust in HaShem's timing and wisdom.
  5. Inner Anxiety and Restlessness: An impatient person is constantly in a state of anxiety and inner turmoil.
  6. Missed Opportunities: Sometimes the best opportunities require patience, and impatience can cause them to be lost.

Related Sources:

  • תורה (Torah):

    • שמות (Shemot - Exodus) 34:6: "יְהוָה יְהוָה אֵל רַחוּם וְחַנּוּן אֶרֶךְ אַפַּיִם וְרַב חֶסֶד וֶאֱמֶת׃" ("HaShem, HaShem, El Rachum VeChanun, Erech Apayim VeRav Chesed VeEmet.") - "HaShem, HaShem, a merciful and gracious G-d, slow to anger and abundant in kindness and truth." The trait of "אֶרֶךְ אַפַּיִם" (Erech Apayim - slow to anger/forbearing) is one of HaShem's primary attributes. We are obligated to cultivate this Divine trait in ourselves as we strive "ללכת בדרכיו" (Lalechet Bi'drachav - to walk in His ways).
    • Bnei Yisrael in the Desert: The narrative of Bnei Yisrael in the desert is full of examples of their impatience (such as demanding meat, the Golden Calf, and constant complaints) and its consequences. These stories teach lessons about the necessity of patience and trust.
    • Moses and his People: Even Moses (as mentioned in previous sections) sinned due to "מצטער" (anger) and impatience, striking the rock instead of speaking to it to bring forth water. This demonstrates that impatience can be challenging even for the greatest figures.
  • תנ"ך (Tanakh - Nevi'im and Ketuvim):

    • משלי (Mishlei - Proverbs) 14:29: "אֶרֶךְ אַפַּיִם רַב תְּבוּנָה וּקְצַר רוּחַ מֵרִים אִוֶּלֶת׃" ("Erech apayim rav tvunah u'ktzar ruach merim ivvelet.") - "He who is slow to anger has great understanding, but he who is short of spirit exalts folly." Impatience (קְצַר רוּחַ - short of spirit) is linked to folly.
    • משלי 16:32: "טוֹב אֶרֶךְ אַפַּיִם מִגִּבּוֹר וּמֹשֵׁל בְּרוּחוֹ מִלֹּכֵד עִיר׃" ("Tov erech apayim mi'gibbor u'moshel be'rucho mi'loched ir.") - "Better is one slow to anger than a mighty man, and he who controls his spirit than he who captures a city." Self-mastery (which includes controlling impatience) is considered the highest form of strength.
    • קוהלת (Kohelet - Ecclesiastes) 7:8: "טוֹב אַחֲרִית דָּבָר מֵרֵאשִׁיתוֹ טוֹב אֶרֶךְ רוּחַ מִגְּבַהּ רוּחַ׃" ("Tov acharit davar mereishito tov erech ruach mi'gevah ruach.") - "Better is the end of a thing than its beginning; and the patient in spirit is better than the proud in spirit." This verse contrasts patience with pride (which can be a root of impatience).
  • מִשְׁנָה (Mishnah):

    • פרקי אבות (Pirkei Avot) 2:16: "לא עליך המלאכה לגמור, ולא אתה בן חורין להבטל ממנה." (It is not your duty to finish the work, but neither are you at liberty to neglect it.) This Mishnah points to the importance of continuous effort and patience in fulfilling duties, even if we cannot immediately see the final outcome.
    • פרקי אבות 4:1: "איזהו גיבור? הכובש את יצרו." (Who is mighty? He who conquers his Yetzer Hara [evil inclination].) Impatience is a Yetzer Hara that must be overcome.
  • תַּלְמוּד (Talmud):

    • בבלי סוטה (Bavli Sotah) 5a: "כל אדם שיש בו גסות רוח, כאילו עובד עבודה זרה." (Anyone who has haughtiness of spirit, it is as if he worships idolatry.) Impatience, stemming from self-centered expectations, is considered a form of pride and "גסות רוח."
    • בבלי יומא (Bavli Yoma) 86b: In the discussion of repentance, it is emphasized that "אפילו עובר עבירה ומתודה, הרי זה עובר עבירה וטוב לו" (Even if one commits a transgression and confesses, he has committed a transgression and it is good for him). This indicates that haste and impatience in repentance can also be harmful.
    • The Talmud emphasizes the importance of "השתדלות" (Hishtadlut - effort/exertion) alongside "בטחון" (Bitachon - trust). This means that one must make an effort, but leave the outcome to HaShem and not be impatient.
  • הלכה (Halakha):

    • רמב"ם (Rambam - Maimonides), משנה תורה (Mishneh Torah), הלכות דעות (Hilchot De'ot - Laws of Ethical Dispositions) 2:3: Rambam considers anger "מידה רעה מאוד" (a very bad trait) and advises one to distance oneself from it greatly. Impatience, as a precursor or form of anger, also falls under this ruling.
    • שולحان עاروخ (Shulchan Aruch): In the laws concerning "הלכות תפילה" (Hilchot Tefillah - Laws of Prayer), the necessity of patience and calmness in prayer is emphasized. Impatience can disrupt the devotion (כוונה - Kavana) in prayer.
  • מוסר (Mussar):

    • מסילת ישרים (Mesillat Yesharim): Ramchal, in the chapters on "זהירות" (Hazehirut - Watchfulness), "נקיות" (Nekiyot - Cleanliness), and especially "סבלנות" (Savlanut - Patience), emphasizes the importance of self-control and avoiding haste and restlessness. He explains that impatience can lead a person to sin.
    • חובות הלבבות (Chovot HaLevavot): Rabbi Bachya ibn Pakuda, in "שער הבטחון" (Gate of Trust), emphasizes the importance of complete trust in HaShem in all matters. Impatience is a sign of a lack of trust that HaShem brings about the best for us at the best time.
    • "אורחות צדיקים" (Orchot Tzaddikim - Paths of the Righteous): This book dedicates an entire chapter to "הכעס" (Anger) and examines impatience as one of its facets. This book considers patience a great virtue and a sign of wisdom.
    • חסידות (Chassidut): Many Chassidic texts emphasize the importance of "התבוננות" (Hitbonenut - deep contemplation) and "שמחה" (Simcha - joy). Impatience hinders both of these. Joy helps a person view situations more positively and become less disheartened.

Common Examples of חֹסֶר סַבְלָנוּת:

  • In Traffic: Getting angry and constantly honking or yelling at other drivers due to delays.
  • In Line for Shopping/Services: Becoming restless, grumbling, or arguing with the salesperson or staff due to a long wait.
  • In Learning/Studying: Quickly giving up on a new subject or difficult skill because one cannot see immediate results.
  • In Parenting: Parents who quickly become frustrated with their children and yell at them for minor mistakes.
  • While Awaiting a Response: Anxiety and anger from not receiving an immediate reply to an email, message, or phone call.
  • In Daily Tasks: Rushing through tasks, eating meals, or speaking in a way that causes distress to oneself or others.
  • In Illness or Physical Problems: Inability to tolerate pain or discomfort, and anger at conditions that require time to heal.

Ways to Overcome חֹסֶר סַבְלָנוּת:

Overcoming impatience requires conscious, continuous, and profound effort to achieve תיקון המידות (rectification of character traits), cultivating סבלנות (patience), אורך רוח (forbearance), שליטה עצמית (self-control), and בִּטָּחוֹן (trust) in HaShem.

  1. Understand the Depth of the Sin and Its Consequences:
    • Understand its Root in Anger: Realize that impatience is a hidden and initial form of anger that can lead to more harmful behaviors.
    • Reflect on the Harm to the Soul: Understand that impatience destroys your inner peace and prevents you from experiencing true joy.
    • Awareness of Lack of Trust: Recognize that impatience is a sign of incomplete trust in HaShem and His Divine timing.
  2. Strengthen יראת שמים (Awe of HaShem), אֱמוּנָה (Faith), and וְעֲנָוָה (True Humility):
    • Emulate HaShem's Attributes (הליכה בדרכיו): Remember that HaShem is "אֶרֶךְ אַפַּיִם" (slow to anger). Strive to cultivate this Divine attribute within yourself.
    • Practice Trust (בִּטָּחוֹן): Consciously trust in HaShem that everything happens at the best time and for your ultimate good.
    • Accept Human Imperfections: Do not expect perfection from yourself or others. Mistakes and delays are part of life's reality.
    • Gratitude (הַכָּרַת הַטּוֹב): Focusing on blessings, instead of shortcomings and delays, helps reduce impatience.
  3. Cultivate Positive Character Traits (תיקון המידות) and Practical Techniques:
    • Self-Awareness and Pause (מודעות והפסקה):
      • Identify Triggers: Understand what situations or thoughts trigger your impatience.
      • Conscious Pause: When you feel impatient, pause for a few moments. Take a deep breath.
      • "השקט והבטח" (Be still and trust): Remind yourself of this phrase.
    • Reset Expectations (איפוס ציפיות):
      • Be Realistic: Accept that not everything will happen immediately and always according to your wishes.
      • Focus on the Process, Not Just the Outcome: Enjoy the journey and the effort itself, not just reaching the destination.
    • Practice Patience in Small Situations:
      • Intentionally stand in a long line and try to remain calm.
      • Choose a time-consuming activity that requires patience (e.g., knitting, cooking, or solving a puzzle).
    • Shift Perspective (שינוי פרספקטיבה):
      • See Divine Wisdom: Understand that even delays can contain wisdom and goodness.
      • Think of Others: Instead of yourself, think of those who might need your help or understanding.
    • Stress Management (ניהול מתחים):
      • Regular Exercise: Physical activity can help reduce stress and increase patience.
      • Sufficient Sleep: Lack of sleep can exacerbate impatience.
      • Healthy Diet: A proper diet influences mood.
    • Focus on the Present (התמקדות בהווה): Instead of rushing to the future, focus on the present moment and its tasks.
  4. Seek Support and Guidance:
    • Consult a רב (Rabbi) or מורה דרך (Spiritual Mentor): They can help you gain a deeper understanding of Jewish teachings on patience, trust, and overcoming impatience.
    • Study Mussar: Mussar texts specifically focus on cultivating patience, combating anger, and self-control.
    • תְּפִלָּה (Tefillah - Prayer): Ask HaShem for the strength and ability to cultivate patience and forbearance.
    • Psychological Counseling: If your impatience significantly impacts your daily life, relationships, or mental health, seeking professional help can be beneficial.

Through continuous practice of these strategies, with strong will, and reliance on HaShem, one can overcome the destructive trait of חֹסֶר סַבְלָנוּת (impatience) and live a life based on tranquility, forbearance, trust, and a true connection with HaShem and others, which will benefit both the individual and society, materially and spiritually.

Stubbornness/Obstinacy (Potentially Stemming from Anger)

עַקְשָׁנוּת / סָרְבָנוּת (Akshanut / Sarvanut - Stubbornness/Obstinacy): Resistance to Truth and Goodness

Stubbornness or obstinacy refers to a state where an individual stubbornly and illogically insists on their opinion, stance, or decision, even when sufficient reasons exist to change it. This trait is strongly condemned in Judaism due to its resistance to truth, logic, and even one's own welfare and the welfare of others. Stubbornness can stem from כַּעַס (Ka'as - anger/wrath) and גַּאֲוָה (Ga'avah - pride/arrogance), as an angry or arrogant person is unwilling to admit their mistake or abandon their position.

Why is stubbornness linked to anger and pride?

  • Hidden Anger: A stubborn person may be angry with themselves, others, or circumstances, and express this anger through obstinacy and lack of cooperation. By being stubborn, they implicitly "punish" others or avoid change.
  • Fear of Admitting Mistakes: Admitting mistakes requires humility. A stubborn person, due to pride, is unwilling to admit they might be wrong and instead insists on their incorrect stance.
  • Need for Control: Stubbornness can be an attempt to maintain control over a situation or people. When an individual feels they are losing control, they react with obstinacy.
  • Hidden Vengefulness: Sometimes obstinacy can be a form of hidden revenge, where an individual harms others by not cooperating or agreeing.
  • Lack of Understanding and Acceptance (חוסר הבנה וקבלה): Stubbornness can arise from an unwillingness to understand other perspectives or to accept divine will.

Stubbornness is a major obstacle on the path of תיקון המידות (Tikun HaMidot - Rectification of Character Traits), תְּשׁוּבָה (Teshuvah - Repentance), and התפתחות אישית ורוחנית (Hitpatchut Ishit VeRuchanit - Personal and Spiritual Growth). The stubborn person gets caught in a cycle of resistance that distances them from truth, happiness, and connection with HaShem and others.


Why is עַקְשָׁנוּת / סָרְבָנוּת problematic?

  1. Resistance to Truth: Stubbornness prevents an individual from accepting the truth, even obvious truth.
  2. Barrier to Repentance and Rectification: For repentance and rectification, one must first admit their mistake, and stubbornness eliminates this possibility.
  3. Damages Relationships: Stubbornness and obstinacy harm friendships, family, and work relationships.
  4. Failure to Benefit from Others' Knowledge and Experience: The stubborn person is unwilling to listen or learn from others.
  5. Missed Opportunities: Stubbornness can lead to the loss of important opportunities for growth and progress.
  6. חִלּוּל הַשֵּׁם (Chilul HaShem - Desecration of HaShem's Name): Stubborn behavior from a religious person presents a negative image of their faith.
  7. Rooted in Pride and Anger: Stubbornness is often a direct result of unchecked pride and anger.

Related Sources:

  • תורה (Torah):

    • שמות (Shemot - Exodus) (Pharaoh and the Israelites): The story of Pharaoh and his obstinacy against HaShem's will to free the Israelites is a classic example of stubbornness. HaShem "hardened" his heart (ויחזק את לב פרעה), but this was in response to Pharaoh's initial obstinacy. This story shows that stubbornness can lead to catastrophic consequences.
    • דברים (Devarim - Deuteronomy) 9:6, 13: "וְיָדַעְתָּ כִּי לֹא בְצִדְקָתְךָ יְהוָה אֱלֹהֶיךָ נֹתֵן לְךָ אֶת הָאָרֶץ הַטּוֹבָה הַזֹּאת לְרִשְׁתָּהּ כִּי עַם קְשֵׁה עֹרֶף אָתָּה׃" ("Ve'yadata ki lo be'tzidkatecha HaShem Elokecha noten lecha et ha'aretz ha'tovah ha'zot le'rishtah ki am ksheh oref attah.") - "Understand, therefore, that it is not because of your righteousness that HaShem your God is giving you this good land to possess, for you are a 'stiff-necked' people [meaning stubborn/obstinate]." The people of Israel are repeatedly rebuked for being "קְשֵׁה עֹרֶף" (stiff-necked), indicating the serious flaw of this trait.
    • Israelites in the Desert: Their constant complaints and refusal to accept Moses's and HaShem's leadership were signs of stubbornness.
  • תנ"ך (Tanakh - Nevi'im u'Ketuvim - Prophets and Writings):

    • משלי (Mishlei - Proverbs) 29:1: "אִישׁ תּוֹכָחוֹת מַקְשֶׁה עֹרֶף פֶּתַע יִשָּׁבֵר וְאֵין מַרְפֵּא׃" ("Ish tochachot maksheh oref peta yishaver ve'ein marpeh.") - "He who is often reproved, yet stiffens his neck [becomes stubborn], will suddenly be broken beyond healing." This verse points to the danger of stubbornness in the face of admonition and rebuke.
    • שמואל א (Shmuel Alef - 1 Samuel) 15:23: "כִּי חַטַּאת קֶסֶם מֶרִי וְאָוֶן וּתְרָפִים הֶפְצַר יַעַן מָאַסְתָּ אֶת דְּבַר יְהוָה וַיִּמְאָסְךָ מִמֶּלֶךְ׃" ("Ki chatat kesem meri ve'aven u'terafim hefzar ya'an ma'asta et devar HaShem va'yima'ascha mi'melech.") - "For rebellion is as the sin of divination, and stubbornness is as iniquity and idolatry. Because you have rejected the word of HaShem, He has also rejected you from being king." This verse likens stubbornness to idolatry, one of the most severe criticisms in Judaism.
    • ירמיהו (Yirmeyahu - Jeremiah) 7:24: "וְלֹא שָׁמְעוּ וְלֹא הִטּוּ אֶת אָזְנָם וַיֵּלְכוּ בְּמֹעֵצוֹת בִּשְׁרִירוּת לִבָּם הָרָע וַיִּהְיוּ לְאָחוֹר וְלֹא לְפָנִים׃" ("Ve'lo sham'u ve'lo hito et oznám va'yelechu bi'mo'etzot bi'shrirut libam ha'ra va'yihyu le'achor ve'lo le'fanim.") - "But they did not listen or incline their ear; rather, they walked in the counsels and in the stubbornness of their evil heart, and went backward and not forward." This verse shows that stubbornness (hardness of heart) hinders spiritual progress.
  • מִשְׁנָה (Mishnah):

    • פרקי אבות (Pirkei Avot) 2:4: "אל תהי חכם בעיניך." (Do not be wise in your own eyes.) Stubbornness often stems from the belief that one is always right and knows better than others.
    • פרקי אבות 4:1: "איזהו גיבור? הכובש את יצרו." (Who is mighty? One who conquers their Yetzer HaRa [evil inclination].) Stubbornness is a strong Yetzer HaRa that must be overcome.
    • פרקי אבות 5:11: "ארבע מידות באדם... קשה לכעוס וקשה לרצות – רשע." (Four traits in a person... slow to anger and slow to appease – he is wicked.) This Mishnah indicates that stubbornness (being slow to appease/obstinate) is a negative trait.
  • תַּלְמוּד (Talmud):

    • בבלי סוטה (Bavli Sotah) 5a: "כל אדם שיש בו גסות רוח, כאילו עובד עבודה זרה." (As mentioned previously) - Stubbornness, which is accompanied by inflexibility and arrogance, stems from pride.
    • בבלי יומא (Bavli Yoma) 86a (regarding repentance): The Talmud emphasizes that true repentance requires "שבירת הלב" (breaking of the heart/pride) and humility. Stubbornness is precisely in opposition to this breaking of the heart.
    • בבלי כתובות (Bavli Ketubot) 112a: "אין כל תלמיד חכם רשאי ללמד הלכה, אלא אם כן ענוותן וירא שמים ומתון ובעל לב טוב." (No Torah scholar is permitted to teach Halakha unless he is humble and God-fearing and patient and has a good heart.) Stubbornness is in contrast with traits like humility and patience.
  • הלכה (Halakha):

    • רמב"ם (Rambam - Maimonides), משנה תורה (Mishneh Torah), הלכות דעות (Hilchot De'ot - Laws of Ethical Traits) 2:3: Rambam considers pride and anger among the worst traits. Stubbornness originates from these roots. Rambam emphasizes that one should cultivate a spirit of "ענווה" (humility) and "קבלת האמת" (acceptance of truth).
    • שולחן ערוך (Shulchan Aruch): In laws concerning interpersonal relationships, the importance of peace, tolerance, and avoiding strife and obstinacy is emphasized.
  • מוסר (Mussar):

    • מסילת ישרים (Mesillat Yesharim): רמח"ל (Ramchal) in the chapters on "הענווה" (Humility) and "הזהירות" (Diligence/Caution), addresses the dangers of inflexibility and stubbornness. He emphasizes that one should always be ready to accept the truth, even if it comes from the humblest person.
    • חובות הלבבות (Chovot HaLevavot): Rabbi Bachya ibn Pakuda in "שער הכניעה" (Gate of Submission) and "שער התשובה" (Gate of Repentance) emphasizes the importance of submission to HaShem's will and avoiding pride and selfishness, of which stubbornness is a practical manifestation.
    • "אורחות צדיקים" (Orchot Tzaddikim - Paths of the Righteous): This book dedicates entire chapters to "הגאווה" (Pride) and "הכעס" (Anger), considering stubbornness one of the worst manifestations of these traits. It advises individuals to always be ready to acknowledge their shortcomings and rectify them.
    • חסידות (Chassidut): Many Chassidic texts emphasize the importance of "ביטול היש" (self-nullification / self-abasement before HaShem). Stubbornness is directly opposed to this principle, as it insists on one's own ego instead of surrendering to HaShem and truth.

Common Examples of עַקְשָׁנוּת / סָרְבָנוּת Manifestation:

  • In Family Disputes: An individual who, despite logical reasons, refuses to back down from their stance in a family argument and insists on it to "win" or "save face."
  • In the Workplace: An employee unwilling to accept constructive feedback or change their work approach, even if it leads to improved performance, simply due to obstinacy.
  • In Religious Matters: A person who, due to a specific tradition or belief, refuses to listen to other interpretations or perspectives of religious texts and stubbornly insists on their own understanding, even if it contradicts logic or other teachings.
  • When Faced with Advice: Someone who, despite knowing that advice is for their own good, refuses to accept it and, due to pride, insists on their mistake.
  • In Daily Affairs: Someone who, even when realizing they've taken a wrong turn, refuses to ask for directions or turn back, and stubbornly continues on the wrong path.

Ways to Overcome עַקְשָׁנוּת / סָרְבָנוּת:

Overcoming stubbornness and obstinacy requires a conscious, continuous, and deep effort towards תיקון המידות (rectification of character traits), cultivating עֲנָוָה (true humility), גמישות מחשבתית (G'mishut Machshevetit - mental flexibility), and קבלת האמת (Kabbalat Ha'Emet - acceptance of truth).

  1. Understanding the Depth of the Sin and its Consequences:
    • Understanding its Roots in Pride and Anger: Deeply understand that stubbornness is a sign of inner weakness, pride, and hidden anger, not strength.
    • Reflecting on the Damage to the Soul: Realize that stubbornness distances you from truth, happiness, and inner peace.
    • Awareness of Chilul HaShem and Analogy to Idolatry: Understand that stubbornness not only harms oneself and others but is also spiritually very dangerous.
  2. Strengthening יראת שמים (Fear of HaShem), אֱמוּנָה (Faith), and עֲנָוָה (True Humility):
    • Submission to HaShem: Remember that only HaShem possesses absolute truth, and we must be humble before His will and wisdom.
    • Practicing Humility (עֲנָוָה): Consciously strive to accept that you might be wrong and don't know everything. Be ready to learn from anyone, regardless of their status.
    • Trust (בִּטָּחוֹן): Trust in HaShem that He will guide you on the right path, even if you have to change your mind.
    • Seeing Others as HaShem's Creations: Instead of seeing others as rivals or enemies, see them as HaShem's creations who may carry truth.
  3. Cultivating Positive Character Traits (תיקון המידות) and Practical Techniques:
    • Honest Self-Reflection (חשבון נפש אמיתי): Regularly and honestly examine the motives behind your stubbornness. Is it fear? Pride? Anger?
    • Thinking Before Reacting (חשיבה לפני תגובה): When in a situation where you feel the urge to be stubborn, pause and ask yourself: "Is my stance logical? Is it beneficial to me or others? Am I acting out of pride or fear?"
    • Practicing Active Listening (הקשבה פעילה): Instead of waiting for your turn to speak, truly listen to what others are saying and try to understand their perspective.
    • Apologizing and Making Amends (התנצלות ותיקון): If you have harmed someone due to stubbornness, humbly apologize and try to make amends.
    • Admitting Mistakes (קבלת טעות): Consciously practice admitting your mistakes and taking responsibility for them.
    • Flexibility (גמישות): Practice being flexible in small matters and cooperating with others. This is a skill that develops with practice.
    • Focus on Common Goal: If you are in a team or family, instead of focusing on being "right" in your position, focus on the common goal and the collective good.
    • Thinking about Consequences: Consider the negative long-term consequences of your stubbornness.
  4. Seeking Support and Guidance:
    • Consulting a הרב (Rabbi) or מורה דרך (Spiritual Mentor): They can help you gain a deeper understanding of Jewish teachings on pride, anger, and stubbornness, and provide practical strategies for overcoming them.
    • Studying Mussar: Mussar texts specifically focus on cultivating humility, flexibility, and combating negative traits like stubbornness.
    • תְּפִלָּה (Tefillah - Prayer): Ask HaShem to soften your heart, grant you humility and wisdom to accept the truth, and keep you from stubbornness.
    • Psychological Counseling: If stubbornness has become a deep-seated behavioral pattern and is seriously affecting your relationships and life, seeking professional help can be very beneficial.

Through continuous practice of these strategies, with strong will, and by relying on HaShem, one can overcome the destructive trait of עַקְשָׁנוּת / סָרְבָנוּת (stubbornness/obstinacy) and lead a life based on truth, humility, flexibility, and true connection with HaShem and others, which will benefit both the individual and society, materially and spiritually.

Hasty Judgment (Which Can Stem From Anger)

שִׁפּוּט חָפוּז (Shiput Chafuz - Hasty Judgment): The Seed of Anger and Injustice

Hasty judgment refers to the tendency to quickly and often negatively conclude about people, situations, or events, without sufficient information or proper deliberation. This trait is closely linked to כַּעַס (Ka'as - anger/wrath) and can be both its root and its consequence. An angry person is often incapable of logical thought and is quickly drawn towards negative and often unjust judgments. Hasty judgment can also be accompanied by גַּאֲוָה (Ga'avah - arrogance/pride) and התנשאות (Hitnasut - haughtiness), where an individual considers themselves superior and quickly condemns others.

Why is hasty judgment related to anger?

  • Stemming from Anger: When a person is angry, their capacity for rational thought and empathy diminishes. They quickly seek to find blame and make swift, harsh, negative judgments without full examination.
  • Causing Anger: Hasty judgment can itself lead to anger. If a person quickly concludes that another has intentionally harmed or disrespected them (without knowing the full truth), this false belief can ignite their anger.
  • Self-Centeredness and Lack of Empathy: Hasty judgment often arises from focusing on "I" and one's limited perspective. The person cannot put themselves in another's shoes and understand their motivations or circumstances. This self-centeredness can lead to anger.
  • Need for Control and Certainty: Some individuals have a strong need for control and certainty. When a situation is ambiguous or doesn't go as expected, they quickly judge to gain a sense of "control" and reduce their anxiety. This attempt at control can result in anger.
  • Suspicion (חשדנות): Hasty judgment often feeds on suspicion, which is the tendency to assume the worst intentions in others, even without evidence. This suspicion can lead to anger.

In Judaism, hasty judgment is strongly condemned and stands in direct opposition to the fundamental principle of דָּן לְכַף זְכוּת (Dan L'Kaf Zechut - judging favorably/giving the benefit of the doubt). This trait not only harms human relationships but also distances a person from the truth and prevents the attainment of true justice and compassion.


Why is שִׁפּוּט חָפוּז problematic?

  1. Injustice and Oppression: Hasty judgment can lead to the unwarranted condemnation of individuals and acts of injustice.
  2. Destruction of Relationships: This behavior erodes trust and leads to alienation in family, friendships, and work relationships.
  3. לָשׁוֹן הָרַע (Lashon HaRa - Slander/Evil Speech): Hasty judgment is often accompanied by Lashon HaRa, as the person transmits what they believe to others without verifying the truth.
  4. Rooted in Pride and Anger: As mentioned, this trait stems from pride (seeing oneself as superior) and anger (inability to think logically).
  5. Barrier to Repentance and Correction: A person who judges hastily may also refuse to admit their own mistakes.
  6. חִלּוּל הַשֵּׁם (Chilul HaShem - Desecration of HaShem's Name): Judgmental and unjust behavior from a religious person presents a negative image of Judaism.

Related Sources:

  • תורה (Torah):

    • ויקרא (Vayikra - Leviticus) 19:15: "לֹא תַעֲשׂוּ עָוֶל בַּמִּשְׁפָּט לֹא תִשָּׂא פְנֵי דָל וְלֹא תֶהְדַּר פְּנֵי גָדוֹל בְּצֶדֶק תִּשְׁפֹּט עֲמִיתֶךָ׃" ("Lo ta'asu avel ba'mishpat lo tissa fenei dal ve'lo tehaddar penei gadol be'tzedek tishpot amitecha.") - "You shall do no injustice in judgment; you shall not be partial to the poor nor defer to the great, but in righteousness shall you judge your neighbor." This verse establishes the foundation of justice in judgment, which includes avoiding haste and prejudice.
    • דניאל (Daniel) 13 (The Story of Susanna): This story, also recounted in the Talmud and Midrash, is cited as an example of hasty judgment and the importance of defending the innocent. Two elderly judges condemn Susanna based on false testimony, but Daniel, with his wisdom, reveals the truth. This story emphasizes the importance of fair judgment and avoiding haste.
  • תנ"ך (Tanakh - Nevi'im u'Ketuvim - Prophets and Writings):

    • משלי (Mishlei - Proverbs) 18:13: "מֵשִׁיב דָּבָר בְּטֶרֶם יִשְׁמָע אִוֶּלֶת הִיא לוֹ וּכְלִמָּה׃" ("Meshiv davar be'terem yishma ivvelet hi lo u'chelimmah.") - "If one answers before he hears, it is folly and shame to him." This verse directly points to the danger of hasty judgment or response.
    • משלי 21:2: "כָּל דֶּרֶךְ אִישׁ יָשָׁר בְּעֵינָיו וְתֹכֵן לִבּוֹת יְהוָה׃" ("Kol derech ish yashar be'einav ve'tochen libbot HaShem.") - "Every way of a man is right in his own eyes, but HaShem weighs the hearts." This verse highlights the truth that we cannot know the true intentions of others, and only HaShem knows what is within.
    • תהלים (Tehilim - Psalms) 14:1: "אָמַר נָבָל בְּלִבּוֹ אֵין אֱלֹהִים הִשְׁחִיתוּ הִתְעִיבוּ עֲלִילָה אֵין עֹשֵׂה טּוֹב׃" ("Amar naval be'libbo ein Elohim hishchitu hit'ivu alilah ein oseh tov.") - "The fool says in his heart, 'There is no G-d.' They are corrupt, their deeds are vile; there is no one who does good." Hasty and negative judgments can lead to a state where a person sees no good in the world.
  • מִשְׁנָה (Mishnah):

    • פרקי אבות (Pirkei Avot) 1:6 (Yehoshua ben Perachya): "יהושע בן פרחיה אומר: עשה לך רב וקנה לך חבר, והוי דן את כל האדם לכף זכות." ("Yehoshua ben Perachya omer: Aseh lecha rav u'k'neh lecha chaver, ve'hevei dan et kol ha'adam le'chaf zechut.") - "Yehoshua ben Perachya says: Appoint for yourself a teacher, acquire a friend, and judge every person favorably." This is one of the most important and well-known admonitions regarding positive judgment.
    • פרקי אבות 2:4: "אל תדון את חברך עד שתגיע למקומו." (Do not judge your fellow until you reach his place.) This Mishnah emphasizes the need for empathy and understanding others' circumstances before judging.
    • פרקי אבות 3:10: "כל אדם שיש בו ג' דברים הללו, תלמיד חכם הוא. וכל אדם שאין בו ג' דברים הללו, אינו תלמיד חכם... אהבת את הבריות, משמח את הבריות, דן את הבריות לכף זכות." (Anyone who possesses these three things is a Torah scholar. And anyone who does not possess these three things is not a Torah scholar... loves people, gladdens people, judges people favorably.) This Mishnah shows that positive judgment is one of the main characteristics of a true scholar.
  • תַּלְמוּד (Talmud):

    • בבלי שבת (Bavli Shabbat) 105b: "כל הכועס – אם חכם הוא, חכמתו מסתלקת ממנו." (Anyone who becomes angry, if he is wise, his wisdom departs from him.) Hasty judgment often stems from anger and a lack of wisdom.
    • בבלי בבא מציעא (Bavli Bava Metzia) 59b (The Oven of Achnai story): This story emphasizes the importance of accepting truth, even against the majority opinion. At the same time, it highlights the importance of respecting scholars and avoiding harshness in debate.
    • The Talmud emphasizes the importance of "בירור הדברים" (Birur HaDvarim - clarification of matters) and "חכמה" (wisdom) in judgment, which requires avoiding haste.
    • The Talmud refers to the importance of "שקט נפשי" (Sheket Nafshi - inner tranquility) which is essential for fair judgment.
  • הלכה (Halakha):

    • רמב"ם (Rambam - Maimonides), משנה תורה (Mishneh Torah), הלכות דעות (Hilchot De'ot - Laws of Ethical Character Traits) 5:10: Rambam emphasizes that one should "דן את כל האדם לכף זכות" (judge all people favorably) and not suspect them.
    • חפץ חיים (Chafetz Chaim - Rabbi Yisrael Meir Kagan), שמירת הלשון (Shmirat HaLashon - Guarding the Tongue): This classic work extensively addresses the laws concerning לָשׁוֹן הָרַע (evil speech) and considers hasty judgment one of its main roots. Rabbi Chafetz Chaim emphasizes that before speaking about others, one must examine all aspects and always assume the best intentions.
  • מוסר (Mussar):

    • מסילת ישרים (Mesillat Yesharim): Ramchal, in the chapters on "זהירות" (Hazehirut - Caution) and "נקיות" (Nekiyot - Purity), emphasizes the need for caution in judgment and avoiding any haste or suspicion. He considers hasty judgment a sign of lack of self-control and insight.
    • חובות הלבבות (Chovot HaLevavot): Rabbi Bachya ibn Pakuda, in "שער הבטחון" (The Gate of Trust), emphasizes the importance of trusting in HaShem and avoiding haste in all matters, including judgment.
    • "אורחות צדיקים" (Orchot Tzaddikim - Paths of the Righteous): This book dedicates an entire chapter to "הדין" (Judgment) and emphasizes the importance of fair judgment and avoiding haste and suspicion.
    • חاخام ישראל סלנטר (Rabbi Yisrael Salanter - Founder of the Mussar Movement): He emphasized the need for "חשבון נפש" (introspection) and self-awareness of inner tendencies towards hasty judgment. He would say: "האדם קרוב אצל עצמו" (A person is close to himself), meaning that we tend to justify ourselves and condemn others.

Common Examples of שִׁפּוּט חָפוּז Manifestation:

  • At Work: A manager who quickly judges an employee's poor performance and labels them "incompetent" without investigating potential reasons (such as personal problems or misunderstanding). This judgment can lead to hasty dismissal.
  • In Social Relationships: Seeing a friend on the street who doesn't greet you and immediately judging that they hate you or have disrespected you, without knowing that they might not have seen you or were in a hurry. This judgment can lead to resentment and strained relations.
  • When encountering someone who is late: Immediately judging them as irresponsible or uncaring, without considering traffic delays or an emergency. This judgment can lead to anger and verbal conflict.
  • Regarding bad news: Hearing incomplete news and immediately drawing negative conclusions and spreading them, without verifying the accuracy of the news or all its details. This can lead to Lashon HaRa.
  • Regarding unpleasant behavior: Seeing unusual behavior from someone and immediately judging them as a bad person, when they might be under pressure or in specific circumstances.

Ways to Overcome שִׁפּוּט חָפוּז:

Overcoming hasty judgment requires a conscious, continuous, and deep effort towards תיקון המידות (the rectification of character traits), cultivating דָּן לְכַף זְכוּת (judging favorably/giving the benefit of the doubt), סבלנות (patience), שליטה עצמית (self-control), and חֶמְלָה (compassion).

  1. Understanding the Gravity of the Sin and its Consequences:
    • Understanding the Danger of Injustice: Deeply understand that hasty judgment can lead to injustice and oppression of others, which are major sins in Judaism.
    • Reflecting on Harm to the Soul: Realize that this trait contaminates your soul and distances you from truth and inner peace.
    • Awareness of חִלּוּל הַשֵּׁם and לָשׁוֹן הָרַע: Recognize that hasty judgment often leads to evil speech and the desecration of HaShem's Name.
  2. Strengthening יראת שמים (Awe of HaShem), אֱמוּנָה (Faith), and וְעֲנָוָה (True Humility):
    • Trust in HaShem (בִּטָּחוֹן): Trust in HaShem, for He knows all things and only He can judge with perfect justice.
    • Emulating HaShem's Attributes: HaShem is merciful and forgiving and "דן לזכות" (judges favorably). We too should strive to cultivate these attributes within ourselves.
    • Practicing Humility (עֲנָוָה): Accept that you do not have all the information and may be mistaken.
    • Gratitude (הַכָּרַת הַטּוֹב): Focusing on blessings can help reduce anger and suspicion.
  3. Cultivating Positive Character Traits (תיקון המידות) and Practical Techniques:
    • Judging Favorably (דָּן לְכַף זְכוּת): This is the most important tool. In every situation, consciously consider the best possible intention for others' actions.
    • Pause and Reflect (הפסקה וחשיבה): Before any judgment or reaction, pause and ask yourself: "Do I have all the information? Is there another reason for this behavior? Am I judging out of anger or haste?"
    • Seek More Information (חיפוש מידע נוסף): If possible, gather more information before judging. Ask questions.
    • Empathy (אמפתיה): Try to put yourself in the other person's shoes and imagine their circumstances.
    • Practice Patience (סבלנות): Accustom yourself to patience when facing ambiguity and uncertainty.
    • Inner Peace (שקט נפשי): The more inner peace you have, the less prone you will be to hasty judgment.
    • Avoiding Gossip (שמירת הלשון): Commit to not speaking about others based on hasty judgments.
    • Admitting Judgmental Mistakes: If you realize you have judged hastily, accept it and apologize to the person concerned (if possible).
  4. Seeking Support and Guidance:
    • Consulting a רב (Rabbi) or מורה דרך (Spiritual Mentor): They can help you gain a deeper understanding of Jewish teachings on fair judgment, דָּן לְכַף זְכוּת, and combating anger.
    • Studying Mussar: Mussar texts specifically focus on cultivating humility, empathy, and avoiding suspicion and hasty judgment.
    • תְּפִלָּה (Tefillah - Prayer): Ask HaShem to grant you the wisdom to judge fairly and avoid suspicion.

Through continuous practice of these strategies, with strong will, and by relying on HaShem, one can overcome the destructive trait of שִׁפּוּט חָפוּז (hasty judgment) and live a life based on truth, justice, compassion, and genuine connection with HaShem and others, which will benefit both the individual and society, materially and spiritually.

Losing Control When Criticized

יְצִיאָה מִשְׁלִיטָה בִּשְׁעַת בִּקֹּרֶת (Yetzia Mi'Shlitah Bi'She'at Bikoret - Losing Control When Criticized): The Challenge of Self-Knowledge and Humility

Losing control when criticized refers to a sudden outburst of anger, verbal aggression, or even physical aggression in response to receiving negative feedback, a reprimand, or correction of a mistake. This reaction is a sign of weakness in controlling כַּעַס (Ka'as - anger/wrath) and גַּאֲוָה (Ga'avah - pride/arrogance). An individual who cannot tolerate criticism often suffers from narcissism, insecurity, or a fear of admitting their own mistakes. In Judaism, this behavior is strongly condemned because it hinders תיקון המידות (Tikun HaMidot - rectification of character traits), תְּשׁוּבָה (Teshuvah - repentance), and personal and spiritual growth.

Why is יְצִיאָה מִשְׁלִיטָה בִּשְׁעַת בִּקֹּרֶת problematic?

  1. Rooted in Pride and Anger: This behavior directly stems from pride and self-importance, which prevent an individual from acknowledging their flaws. Anger also acts as a defense mechanism to cope with the feeling of vulnerability caused by criticism.
  2. Resistance to Truth and Correction: If we cannot accept criticism, we cannot recognize our mistakes and correct them. This prevents personal and spiritual growth.
  3. Damaging Relationships: Angry reactions to criticism destroy relationships because people become afraid to offer you honest feedback.
  4. חִלּוּל הַשֵּׁם (Chilul HaShem - Desecration of HaShem's Name): Aggressive behavior from a religious person in the face of criticism presents a negative image of Judaism and can cause others to distance themselves from HaShem's path.
  5. Loss of Learning Opportunities: Criticism, even if poorly delivered, can contain valuable insights for learning. Missing out on learning opportunities is a significant loss.
  6. Indicates Lack of שליטה עצמית (Self-Control): The ability to accept criticism calmly is a sign of strength and self-control, while losing control is a sign of weakness and lack of control.

Related Sources:

  • תורה (Torah):

    • ויקרא (Vayikra - Leviticus) 19:17: "לֹא תִשְׂנָא אֶת אָחִיךָ בִּלְבָבֶךָ הוֹכֵחַ תּוֹכִיחַ אֶת עֲמִיתֶךָ וְלֹא תִשָּׂא עָלָיו חֵטְא׃" ("Lo tisna et achicha bilvavecha hochach tochiach et amitecha ve'lo tissa alav chet.") - "You shall not hate your brother in your heart; you shall surely rebuke [admonish/criticize] your fellow, and not bear sin because of him." This verse commands us to admonish each other and point out mistakes. An angry reaction to this admonition violates this command and prevents others from fulfilling it.
    • Daniel 13 (Story of Susanna): Daniel challenges the hasty criticism and judgment of the elders. A wise person should be ready to accept such challenges.
    • Story of Moses and בני ישראל (Bnei Yisrael - Children of Israel): Moses repeatedly faced the complaints and (unjust) criticisms of the Children of Israel, but he dealt with them patiently and with self-restraint. Even when HaShem was angry with them, Moses interceded for them. This pattern is an example of managing criticism without losing control.
  • תנ"ך (Tanakh - Nevi'im u'Ketuvim - Prophets and Writings):

    • משלי (Mishlei - Proverbs) 9:8: "אַל תּוֹכַח לֵץ פֶּן יִשְׂנָאֶךָּ הוֹכַח לְחָכָם וְיֶאֱהָבֶךָּ׃" ("Al tochach letz pen yisna'eka hochach le'chacham ve'ye'ehavka.") - "Do not rebuke a scoffer, lest he hate you; rebuke a wise man, and he will love you." This verse shows that a wise person accepts and appreciates criticism, while a foolish person despises it. Losing control is a sign of foolishness.
    • משלי 12:1: "אֹהֵב מִשְׁמַעַת אֹהֵב דַּעַת וְשֹׂנֵא תוֹכַחַת בָּעַר׃" ("Ohev mishma'at ohev da'at ve'soneh tochachat ba'ar.") - "Whoever loves discipline loves knowledge, but whoever hates correction is stupid." This verse clearly shows the connection between accepting criticism and knowledge.
    • משלי 15:31: "אֹזֶן שֹׁמַעַת תּוֹכַחַת חַיִּים בְּקֶרֶב חֲכָמִים תָּלִין׃" ("Ozen shoma'at tochachat chayyim be'kerev chachamim talin.") - "The ear that listens to life-giving correction will dwell among the wise." Accepting criticism is key to life and wisdom.
    • משלי 27:6: "נֶאֶמָנִים פִּצְעֵי אוֹהֵב וְנַעְתָּרוֹת נְשִׁיקוֹת שׂוֹנֵא׃" ("Ne'emanim pitzei ohev ve'na'tarot neshikot soneh.") - "Faithful are the wounds of a friend, but profuse are the kisses of an enemy." A friend's criticism, even if painful, is for our benefit.
  • מִשְׁנָה (Mishnah):

    • פרקי אבות (Pirkei Avot) 2:4: "אל תהי חכם בעיניך." (Do not be wise in your own eyes.) Losing control when criticized stems from the belief of "I am always right."
    • פרקי אבות 4:1: "איזהו גיבור? הכובש את יצרו." (Who is mighty? One who conquers his יצר הרע [evil inclination].) Controlling anger during criticism is a sign of true strength.
    • פרקי אבות 4:18: "לֵיצָנוּת וְעַצְבוּת מַרְחִיקִין אֶת הָאָדָם מִן הַחֲכָמִים." (Scoffing and sadness distance a person from the wise.) Instead of scoffing at or being saddened by criticism, one should learn from it.
  • תַּלְמוּד (Talmud):

    • בבלי פסחים (Bavli Pesachim) 66b: "כל הכועס, כאילו עובד עבודה זרה." (Whoever gets angry, it is as if he worships idols.) Losing control in the face of criticism is the height of this self-idolatry.
    • בבלי יומא (Bavli Yoma) 86a (regarding repentance): Repentance requires "שבירת הלב" (breaking of the heart/pride). One who gets angry at criticism is not willing to break their pride.
    • Numerous sections in the Talmud discuss "תוכחה" (Tochachah - rebuke/admonition) and how to accept it. The Talmud emphasizes the importance of accepting rebuke from anyone, even a child.
    • The Talmud refers to the importance of "ביטול היש" (nullifying one's existence / self-abnegation before HaShem) which is in contrast to the pride and arrogance that lead to losing control when criticized.
  • הלכה (Halakha):

    • רמב"ם (Rambam - Maimonides), משנה תורה (Mishneh Torah), הלכות דעות (Hilchot De'ot - Laws of Character Traits) 2:3: Rambam considers anger a "very bad measure" (מידה רעה מאוד) and warns against it, as it is the root of many sins, including not accepting criticism and aggression. He emphasizes that one must cultivate a spirit of "ענווה" (humility) and "קבלת האמת" (acceptance of truth).
    • חפץ חיים (Chafetz Chaim - Rabbi Yisrael Meir HaKohen), שמירת הלשון (Shmirat HaLashon - Guarding the Tongue): Although this book primarily addresses sins of speech, implicitly, losing control with harsh words and insults is a form of לָשׁוֹן הָרַע (lashon hara - evil speech) that must be avoided.
  • מוסר (Mussar):

    • מסילת ישרים (Mesillat Yesharim): Ramchal, in the chapters on "הענווה" (Humility) and "הזהירות" (Diligence/Watchfulness), extensively discusses the importance of accepting truth and avoiding pride. He emphasizes that a truly righteous person is receptive even to the slightest criticism and uses it for their growth.
    • חובות הלבבות (Chovot HaLevavot): Rabbi Bachya ibn Pakuda, in "שער הענווה" (Gate of Humility), emphasizes the importance of humility and avoiding self-conceit, which is the root cause of losing control when criticized.
    • "אורחות צדיקים" (Orchot Tzaddikim - Paths of the Righteous): This book has detailed chapters on "הגאווה" (Pride) and "הכעס" (Anger) and specifically addresses the destructive consequences of these traits, including the inability to accept criticism. This book emphasizes the importance of "ביטול רצון" (nullifying one's will before HaShem's will and truth).
    • חاخام ישראל סלנטר (Rabbi Yisrael Salanter): He emphasized the necessity of "חשבון נפש" (soul-accounting) and self-awareness of inner tendencies that lead to losing control when criticized. He believed that only by precisely recognizing weaknesses can one overcome them.

Common Examples of יְצִיאָה מִשְׁלִיטָה בִּשְׁעַת בִּקֹּרֶת:

  • In the workplace:
    • A manager who reacts with anger and reprimands an employee instead of listening to their feedback on a project.
    • An employee who receives criticism from their boss about their performance and immediately reacts with justification, counter-attack, or threats of resignation.
  • In family relationships:
    • A spouse who, when criticized by their partner, loses control by shouting, cursing, or leaving the room.
    • A child who receives a reprimand from their parents about inappropriate behavior and reacts with aggression or intense crying.
  • In academic/social settings:
    • A student who receives a low grade from their professor and, instead of asking for clarification, reacts with anger and disrespect towards the professor.
    • An individual who is criticized in a social discussion and, instead of a logical response, loses control with personal attacks and anger.
  • When facing religious admonition:
    • An individual who receives a reprimand from a Rabbi or religious scholar about their behavior and reacts with anger and resistance to it.

Ways to Overcome יְצִיאָה מִשְׁלִיטָה בִּשְׁעַת בִּקֹּרֶת:

Overcoming losing control when criticized requires a conscious, continuous, and deep effort for תיקון המידות (rectification of character traits), cultivating עֲנָוָה (Anavah - humility), אורך רוח (Orech Ruach - patience/long-suffering), שליטה עצמית (Shlitah Atzmit - self-control), and חכמה (Chokmah - wisdom).

  1. Understand the Depth of the Sin and Its Consequences:
    • Understand its Root in Pride and Anger: Deeply understand that this behavior is a sign of pride and insecurity, not strength.
    • Reflect on the Harm to the Soul: Understand that this behavior pollutes your soul and prevents closeness to HaShem and true growth.
    • Awareness of חִלּוּל הַשֵּׁם and Lost Opportunities: Recognize that this act devalues HaShem's Name and religion, and deprives you of opportunities for learning and improvement.
  2. Strengthen יראת שמים (Fear of Heaven/Reverence for HaShem), אֱמוּנָה (Emunah - Faith), and וְעֲנָוָה (True Humility):
    • HaShem's Presence and Divine Insight: Remind yourself that HaShem is aware of everything and only He knows the absolute truth.
    • Acceptance of Human Imperfections: All humans are imperfect and make mistakes. Humility means accepting this truth.
    • Practice Humility (עֲנָוָה): Consciously strive to break your pride. Remind yourself that any criticism, even if ill-intentioned, can contain a grain of truth that is beneficial for your growth.
    • Trust (בִּטָּחוֹן): Trust in HaShem that even through criticism, He desires your good.
  3. Cultivate Positive Character Traits (תיקון המידות) and Practical Techniques:
    • Self-Awareness (מודעות עצמית): Identify your triggers. Know what types of criticism make you most angry and in what situations you are prone to losing control.
    • Pause and Deep Breathing (הפסקה ונשימה עמוקה): The moment you hear criticism, before any reaction, take a few deep breaths. This gives you time to calm down and think.
    • Active Listening (הקשבה פעילה): Instead of searching for an answer or defense in your mind, truly listen to what the other person is saying. Try to understand their perspective.
    • Seek Clarity (חיפוש בהירות): If the criticism is vague, ask clarifying questions: "What exactly do you mean?" "Can you give an example?"
    • Acknowledge the Criticism (הכרה בביקורת): Even if you don't agree with the criticism, thank the other person for taking the time to express their opinion. This shows your respect.
    • Practice Patience (סבלנות): Be patient with the feelings of discomfort or anger arising from criticism. Allow the emotions to subside.
    • Consider the Truth (בחינת האמת): After hearing the criticism and calming down, logically examine it. Is there any point in it from which you can learn?
    • Rectification and Repentance (תיקון ותשובה): If you have offended or harmed someone by losing control, humbly apologize and work to repair the relationship.
    • Self-Education (חינוך עצמי): Remind yourself that criticism is an opportunity for growth.
  4. Seek Support and Guidance:
    • Consult with a רב (Rabbi) or מורה דרך (spiritual mentor): They can help you gain a deeper understanding of Jewish teachings on anger, pride, humility, and how to accept criticism.
    • Study Mussar: Mussar texts specifically focus on cultivating humility, patience, and combating anger and pride.
    • תְּפִלָּה (Tefillah - Prayer): Ask HaShem to grant you the strength of self-control, humility, and wisdom to accept and utilize criticism.
    • Psychological Counseling: If your reactions to criticism are severe and uncontrollable and are causing serious damage to your relationships, seeking help from a psychologist or therapist for anger management, working on self-esteem, and learning healthy communication skills is essential.

Through continuous practice of these strategies, with strong will, and by relying on HaShem, one can overcome the destructive trait of יְצִיאָה מִשְׁלִיטָה בִּשְׁעַת בִּקֹּרֶת (losing control when criticized) and live a life based on growth, learning, humility, and a genuine connection with HaShem and others, which will benefit both the individual and society materially and spiritually.

Ill-Temperedness/Sourness

רֹעַ לֵב / קַפְּדָנוּת (Ro'a Lev / Kapdanut - Ill-Temperedness/Sourness): The Poison of Relationships and the Soul

Ill-temperedness or sourness refers to a persistent and deeply rooted behavioral state of grumpiness, harshness, irritability, and unpleasantness in interactions with others. This trait is a clear manifestation of chronic and unmanaged כַּעַס (Ka'as - anger/wrath) that quietly poisons relationships and destroys peace. An ill-tempered person often reacts negatively and sharply without justifiable reason, as if perpetually dissatisfied. This trait is condemned not only because of its origin in anger but also due to its destructive impact on human relationships, the home and workplace environment, and, of course, on the individual's own spirit and psyche, making it severely reproached in Judaism.

Why is רֹעַ לֵב / קַפְּדָנוּת problematic?

  1. Rooted in Chronic Anger and Lack of Self-Control: Ill-temperedness is the result of an inability to manage inner anger and aggression, which, instead of sudden outbursts, manifests as a constant state of dissatisfaction and grumpiness.
  2. Destruction of Human Relationships: Nothing erodes family, friendly, and professional relationships as much as ill-temperedness. This trait pushes people away, creates an atmosphere of tension and discomfort, and prevents closeness and intimacy.
  3. Violation of צֶלֶם אֱלֹהִים (Tzelem Elokim - The Divine Image): Ill-tempered behaviors disrespect the dignity and peace of others, who are created in the image of HaShem.
  4. חִלּוּל הַשֵּׁם (Chilul HaShem - Desecration of HaShem's Name): If a religious person is ill-tempered, it presents a negative image of Judaism and can lead others away from HaShem's path.
  5. Hindrance to Spiritual Growth: Ill-temperedness alienates the human soul from peace, joy, and gratitude. This trait obstructs the path to "שְׁלֵמוּת" (Shleimut - wholeness/perfection) and "קְדוּשָׁה" (Kedushah - holiness).
  6. Seed of Other Sins: Ill-temperedness can lead to לָשׁוֹן הָרַע (slander/evil speech), hasty judgment, and even other verbal and psychological harms.

Related Sources:

  • תורה (Torah):

    • דברים (Devarim - Deuteronomy) 10:12: "וְעַתָּה יִשְׂרָאֵל מָה יְהוָה אֱלֹהֶיךָ שֹׁאֵל מֵעִמָּךְ כִּי אִם לְיִרְאָה אֶת יְהוָה אֱלֹהֶיךָ לָלֶכֶת בְּכָל דְּרָכָיו וּלְאַהֲבָה אֹתוֹ וְלַעֲבֹד אֶת יְהוָה אֱלֹהֶיךָ בְּכָל לְבָבְךָ וּבְכָל נַפְשֶׁךָ׃" ("Ve'attah Yisrael mah HaShem Eloheicha shoel me'immach ki im le'yira et HaShem Eloheicha lalechet be'chol d'rachav u'le'ahavah oto ve'la'avod et HaShem Eloheicha be'chol levavcha u've'chol nafshecha.") - "And now, Israel, what does HaShem your God ask of you, but to fear HaShem your God, to walk in all His ways, and to love Him, and to serve HaShem your God with all your heart and with all your soul." HaShem's way is a way of kindness, love, and peace, which stands in contrast to ill-temperedness.
    • Many stories in the Torah emphasize the importance of good conduct and kindness. For example, Abraham's kind treatment of strangers serves as an example of avoiding ill-temperedness.
  • תנ"ך (Tanakh - Nevi'im u'Ketuvim - Prophets and Writings):

    • משלי (Mishlei - Proverbs) 15:1: "מַעֲנֶה רַּךְ יָשִׁיב חֵמָה וּדְבַר עֶצֶב יַעֲלֶה אָף׃" ("Ma'aneh rach yashiv chemah u'devar etzev ya'aleh af.") - "A soft answer turns away wrath, but a harsh word stirs up anger." Ill-temperedness is associated with "harsh words" that increase wrath.
    • משלי 21:9: "טוֹב לָשֶׁבֶת עַל פִּנַּת גָּג מֵאֵשֶׁת מִדְיָנִים וּבֵית חָבֶר׃" ("Tov lashevet al pinnat gag me'eshet midyanim u'veit chaver.") - "It is better to live on a corner of a rooftop than with a quarrelsome wife in a shared house." This verse alludes to the difficulty of living with an ill-tempered person.
    • משלי 25:24: "טוֹב לָשֶׁבֶת עַל פִּנַּת גָּג מֵאֵשֶׁת מִדְיָנִים וּבֵית חָבֶר׃" (A repetition of verse 21:9, emphasizing this truth.)
    • משלי 29:22: "אִישׁ אַף יְגָרֶה מָדוֹן וּבַעַל חֵמָה רַב פֶּשַׁע׃" ("Ish af yegareh madon u'ba'al chemah rav pesha.") - "An angry person stirs up strife, and a furious person is full of transgression." Ill-temperedness is the constant manifestation of this "fury" and being "full of transgression."
  • מִשְׁנָה (Mishnah):

    • פרקי אבות (Pirkei Avot) 2:10: "כל הכועס – אם חכם הוא, חכמתו מסתלקת ממנו..." (Whoever becomes angry – if he is wise, his wisdom departs from him...) - Ill-temperedness, due to chronic anger, prevents the acquisition of wisdom and knowledge.
    • פרקי אבות 2:16: "רַבִּי טַרְפוֹן אוֹמֵר: הַיּוֹם קָצָר, וְהַמְּלָאכָה מְרֻבָּה, וְהַפּוֹעֲלִים עֲצֵלִים, וְהַשָּׂכָר הַרְבֵּה, וּבַעַל הַבַּיִת דּוֹחֵק.2 לֹא עָלֶיךָ הַמְּלָאכָה לִגְמֹר, וְלֹא אַתָּה בֶּן חוֹרִין לְהִבָּטֵל מִמֶּנָּה." (Rabbi Tarfon says: The day is short, and the work is great, and the laborers are lazy, and the reward is much, and the Master is pressing. It is not your duty to finish the work, but neither are you at liberty to neglect it.) This Mishnah emphasizes the need for positivity, effort, and avoiding complaining (which accompanies ill-temperedness).
  • תַּלְמוּד (Talmud):

    • בבלי פסחים (Bavli Pesachim) 66b: "כל הכועס, כאילו עובד עבודה זרה." (Whoever becomes angry, it is as if he worships idols.) Ill-temperedness, being a constant manifestation of anger, distances a person from HaShem.
    • בבלי נדרים (Bavli Nedarim) 22b: "כל אדם הכועס, כל מיני גיהינום שולטים בו." (Every person who is angry, all kinds of Gehinnom (hell) rule over him.) This refers to the spiritual and emotional consequences of chronic anger and ill-temperedness.
    • The Talmud emphasizes the importance of "דרך ארץ קדמה לתורה" (Derech Eretz Kadmah LeTorah - Proper conduct precedes Torah). Ill-temperedness is in direct contradiction to this principle.
    • The Talmud places great importance on "שלום בית" (Shalom Bayit - peace in the home) and "שלום בין אדם לחברו" (Shalom Bein Adam LeChavero - peace between a person and their fellow). Ill-temperedness disrupts both.
  • הלכה (Halakha):

    • רמב"ם (Rambam - Maimonides), משנה תורה (Mishneh Torah), הלכות דעות (Hilchot De'ot - Laws of Ethical Dispositions) 2:3: Rambam considers anger a "very bad measure" (מידה רעה מאוד) and warns against it, as it is the root of many sins, including ill-temperedness. He emphasizes that one should be moderate, neither too "כועס" (angry) nor too "מצחק" (jovial), but concerning anger, one should eradicate it completely.
    • Rabbi חפץ חיים (Chafetz Chaim - Rabbi Yisrael Meir HaCohen), שמירת הלשון (Shmirat HaLashon - Guarding the Tongue): This book extensively addresses sins of speech and prohibits any negative talk, endless complaining, grumbling, and hurtful speech, all of which are manifestations of ill-temperedness.
  • מוסר (Mussar):

    • מסילת ישרים (Mesillat Yesharim): Ramchal, in the chapters on "הזהירות" (Caution), "הנקיות" (Cleanliness), and especially "הפרישות" (Separation/Abstinence), emphasizes the necessity of controlling emotions and avoiding any "מידה רעה" (bad trait). He considers ill-temperedness a major obstacle to spiritual growth and feeling closeness to HaShem.
    • חובות הלבבות (Chovot HaLevavot): Rabbi Bachya ibn Pakuda, in "שער הבטחון" (Gate of Trust) and "שער התשובה" (Gate of Repentance), stresses the importance of trusting in HaShem and avoiding dissatisfaction and resentment, which are at the root of ill-temperedness.
    • "אורחות צדיקים" (Orchot Tzaddikim - Paths of the Righteous): This book has detailed chapters on "הכעס" (anger) and "העצבות" (sadness) and specifically addresses the destructive consequences of these traits, including ill-temperedness. The book emphasizes the importance of "שמחה" (joy) and "פנים שוחקות" (smiling face).
    • Rabbi ישראל סלנטר (Rabbi Yisrael Salanter): He emphasized the necessity of "חשבון נפש" (introspection) and self-awareness of one's inner tendencies towards ill-temperedness. He believed that one must continuously work on one's ethical traits to achieve "שליטה" (control) over oneself.

Common Examples of רֹעַ לֵב / קַפְּדָנוּת Manifestations:

  • At Home:
    • A parent who constantly complains, is dissatisfied with everything, and reacts harshly to the slightest mistakes of their children or spouse.
    • A spouse who is always grumpy without reason, speaks in a sharp tone, and fills the home with tension.
    • A child who always complains about food, clothes, or anything else, and is ill-tempered when interacting with others.
  • In the Workplace:
    • A manager who is always ill-tempered with their employees, never smiles, and speaks in a dry and harsh tone.
    • A colleague who is ill-tempered in all meetings, complains, and brings down everyone else's morale.
    • An employee who is dissatisfied with the smallest changes and grumbles.
  • In Social Relationships:
    • An individual who always has a negative outlook in social gatherings, criticizes others, and, instead of cheering up the atmosphere, makes it heavy.
    • Someone who is ill-tempered with staff in a shop or office and yells at them without justifiable reason.
    • A neighbor who is always complaining about everything and speaks to others in a hostile tone.

Ways to Overcome רֹעַ לֵב / קַפְּדָנוּת:

Overcoming ill-temperedness/sourness requires a conscious, continuous, and deep effort for תיקון המידות (Tikun HaMiddot - rectifying character traits), cultivating שליטה עצמית (Shlitah Atzmit - self-control), אורך רוח (Orech Ruach - patience/long-suffering), עֲנָוָה (Anavah - humility), שמחה (Simcha - joy), and אהבת הבריות (Ahavat HaBriyot - love of fellow beings).

  1. Understanding the Depth of the Sin and its Consequences:
    • Understanding its Root in Inner Anger and Dissatisfaction: Deeply comprehend that ill-temperedness is a sign of profound inner dissatisfaction and a lack of peace.
    • Reflecting on the Harm to the Soul: Understand that this trait pollutes your soul, distances you from HaShem, and prevents you from experiencing true joy and peace.
    • Awareness of חִלּוּל הַשֵּׁם and Relationship Destruction: Recognize that this act devalues HaShem's name and the faith, and destroys relationships with your loved ones.
  2. Strengthening יראת שמים (Fear of HaShem), אֱמוּנָה (Emunah - faith), and וְשִׂמְחָה (Simcha - true joy):
    • HaShem's Presence and Accountability: Remind yourself that HaShem is always present and watching, and that you are responsible for how you interact with others.
    • Focus on Blessings (הַכָּרַת הַטּוֹב): Instead of focusing on negative aspects, consciously focus on the blessings and good things in your life. Gratitude is the antidote to ill-temperedness.
    • Acceptance of Human Imperfections and Divine Providence: Accept that not everything is under your control. Trust in HaShem can reduce dissatisfaction.
    • Cultivating Joy (שמחה): Seek ways to create joy in your life, whether through Torah study, performing מצוות (Mitzvot - commandments), or spending time with loved ones. Inner joy dispels ill-temperedness.
  3. Cultivating Positive Ethical Traits (תיקון המידות) and Practical Techniques:
    • Managing Chronic Anger (ניהול כעס כרוני):
      • Identifying Roots: Look for deeper reasons for your ill-temperedness: Are you stressed? Not getting enough sleep? Dissatisfied with something in your life?
      • Pause and Breathe: In moments of feeling ill-tempered, pause and take a few deep breaths.
      • Physical State Change: If standing, sit down; if sitting, stand up.
      • Exercise and Physical Activity: Exercise regularly. Physical activity can help manage stress and anger.
    • Practicing Gentle Speech and a Welcoming Demeanor (פנים שוחקות ודיבור רך): Consciously strive to speak to others in a calm tone and with a welcoming face, even if you don't feel well.
    • Practicing דָּן לְכַף זְכוּת (Giving the Benefit of the Doubt): Instead of assuming the worst intentions in others, always consider the best possible intention.
    • Rectification and Repentance (תיקון ותשובה): If you have harmed someone due to ill-temperedness, humbly apologize and strive to repair the relationship.
    • Mussar Study: Mussar texts specifically focus on cultivating joy, patience, humility, and avoiding anger and dissatisfaction.
    • Setting Small Goals: Set small behavioral change goals, such as "Today I will smile once" or "Today I will say thank you instead of complaining."
  4. Seeking Support and Guidance:
    • Consulting a רב (Rabbi) or מורה דרך (Moreh Derech - spiritual mentor): They can help you gain a deeper understanding of Jewish teachings on anger, ill-temperedness, and cultivating joy and peace.
    • תְּפִלָּה (Tefillah - Prayer): Ask HaShem for the strength to control your impulses, avoid ill-temperedness, and possess a heart full of joy and kindness.
    • Psychological Counseling: If your ill-temperedness has deeper roots in depression, anxiety, or other mental health issues, seeking help from a psychologist or therapist is essential for managing these issues.

Through continuous practice of these strategies, with strong will, and by relying on HaShem, one can overcome the destructive trait of רֹעַ לֵב / קַפְּדָנוּת (ill-temperedness/sourness) and live a life based on peace, joy, healthy relationships, and a genuine connection with HaShem and others, which will benefit both the individual and society, materially and spiritually.

5. Resentment and Vengeance

This category addresses the long-term, destructive consequences of unmanaged anger: holding onto resentment and the desire for revenge. These traits not only harm the soul of the resentful individual but also perpetuate an endless cycle of violence and hatred, contradicting the fundamental principles of forgiveness and divine justice.


Bearing a Grudge and Vengeance (Netirat HaKamma, Nekamah)

This section includes נְטִירַת הַקָּמָא (Netirat HaKamma - bearing a grudge) and נְקָמָה (Nekamah - vengeance). These are the most severe and prolonged manifestations of unmanaged anger. Bearing a grudge is a chronic feeling of bitterness and resentment, while vengeance is the act of harming someone who has previously harmed you. Both are strictly prohibited in Judaism and prevent true liberation and peace.

Why are these sins serious? How to Overcome:
  1. Belief in Divine Justice: Accept that HaShem is fair and will ultimately establish justice.
  2. Conscious Decision to Forgive (Slicha): Forgiveness is an active decision. Even if you cannot change your feelings, decide to let go of resentment and not seek revenge.
  3. Practice Bitachon (Trust): Trust in HaShem that He is in control of matters and there is no need for worry or resentment.
  4. Express Emotions in a Healthy Way: Instead of suppressing anger, express it in a healthy manner (e.g., by talking, writing, or physical activity).
  5. Pray for the Other Person: Even if it's difficult, wish well for the person who has harmed you.
  6. Focus on Building, Not Destroying: Direct your energy towards creating positive things in your own life and the lives of others.
  7. Psychological Counseling: If resentment or the desire for revenge is deep and chronic, seek help from a professional.

Holding a Grudge (Which Can Stem from Anger)

נְטִירַת הַקָּמָא (Netirat HaKamma - Holding a Grudge): A Poison for the Soul

Holding a grudge (נְטִירַת הַקָּמָא) refers to the chronic feeling of anger, bitterness, and resentment towards someone who has harmed or offended you in the past. This state is a deep and destructive manifestation of unmanaged כַּעַס (Ka'as - anger/wrath) that accumulates within an individual, preventing liberation and peace. A grudge is condemned in Judaism not only because it originates from anger, but also due to its destructive effects on the grudge-holder's soul and psyche, human relationships, and even their ability to connect with HaShem.

Why is נְטִירַת הַקָּמָא Problematic?

  1. Direct Violation of מצוות (Commandments): The Torah explicitly forbids holding grudges.
  2. Poison for the Soul: A grudge acts like a poison that contaminates the human soul, destroys joy, and prevents feelings of inner peace and tranquility.
  3. Rooted in Anger and Lack of Trust: A grudge is a sign of deep-seated anger and an inability to forgive and let go. It can also stem from a lack of trust in HaShem to administer justice.
  4. Destroys Relationships: A grudge creates a high wall between a person and their fellow human being. It cools and darkens relationships, preventing intimacy and empathy.
  5. Hindrance to Repentance and Spiritual Growth: A grudge-holder cannot fully repent, as by holding onto resentment, they deprive themselves of divine forgiveness and mercy. This hinders spiritual growth and progress.
  6. חילול השם (Chilul HaShem - Desecration of HaShem's Name): Grudge-holding behavior from a religious person presents a negative image of Judaism and can cause others to distance themselves from HaShem's path.
  7. Increases Suffering and Discomfort: A grudge does not only harm the offending individual, but primarily harms the grudge-holder themselves, trapping them in an endless cycle of suffering and discomfort.

Related Sources:

  • תורה (Torah):

    • ויקרא (Vayikra - Leviticus) 19:18: "לֹא תִקֹּם וְלֹא תִטֹּר אֶת בְּנֵי עַמֶּךָ וְאָהַבְתָּ לְרֵעֲךָ כָּמוֹךָ אֲנִי יְהוָה׃" ("Lo tikkom ve'lo tittor et benei ammecha ve'ahavta le're'acha kamocha Ani HaShem.") - "You shall not take vengeance or bear a grudge against the sons of your people, but you shall love your neighbor as yourself: I am HaShem." This verse is the most explicit and direct prohibition against holding a grudge (נטירה - Netirah) in the Torah, placing it alongside the commandment to "love your neighbor" to show the clear contradiction between these two concepts.
    • The Story of Joseph and His Brothers (בראשית - Bereishit): After years of separation and suffering, Joseph forgives his brothers and releases his grudge. This story is an inspiring example of the power of forgiveness and letting go of resentment.
  • תנ"ך (Tanakh - Nevi'im u'Ketuvim - Prophets and Writings):

    • משלי (Mishlei - Proverbs) 10:12: "שִׂנְאָה תְּעוֹרֵר מְדָנִים וְעַל כָּל פְּשָׁעִים תְּכַסֶּה אַהֲבָה׃" ("Sin'ah te'orer medaním ve'al kol pesha'im techasseh ahavah.") - "Hatred stirs up strife, but love covers all offenses." A grudge originates from hatred and is a primary cause of strife and lack of peace.
    • Mishlei 26:27: "כֹּרֶה שַּׁחַת בָּהּ יִפֹּל וְגֹלֵל אֶבֶן אֵלָיו תָּשׁוּב׃" ("Koreh shachat bah yippol ve'golel even elav tashuv.") - "Whoever digs a pit will fall into it, and a stone that is rolled will come back on him." Holding a grudge is akin to digging a pit or rolling a stone, ultimately harming the individual themselves.
    • Psalms 37:8: "הֶרֶף מֵאַף וַעֲזֹב חֵמָה אַל תִּתְחַר אַךְ לְהָרֵעַ׃" ("Heraf me'af ve'azov chemah al tit'char ach le'hare'a.") - "Refrain from anger and forsake wrath; do not fret; it leads only to evil." A grudge is a persistent manifestation of anger and wrath that must be released.
  • מִשְׁנָה (Mishnah):

    • פרקי אבות (Pirkei Avot) 2:10: "כל הכועס – אם חכם הוא, חכמתו מסתלקת ממנו..." (Whoever is angry, if he is wise, his wisdom departs from him...) - A grudge, due to hidden anger, hinders wisdom and insight.
    • פרקי אבות 4:1: "איזהו גיבור? הכובש את יצרו." (Who is mighty? He who conquers his Yetzer Hara [evil inclination].) Overcoming a grudge is the greatest sign of strength.
  • תַּלְמוּד (Talmud):

    • בבלי יומא (Bavli Yoma) 86b: In the discussion about "תְּשׁוּבָה" (repentance), the Talmud states that sins between a person and their fellow human being (בין אדם לחברו - Bein Adam LeChavero) will not be forgiven until forgiveness is sought from the wronged individual. Grudge-holding prevents this process of forgiveness.
    • בבלי ראש השנה (Bavli Rosh HaShanah) 17a: The Talmud emphasizes the importance of forgiveness and letting go of grudges, stating that if a person forgives another, HaShem will also forgive them.
    • בבלי שבת (Bavli Shabbat) 119a: "מפני מה חרב הבית השני? מפני שנאת חינם." (Why was the Second Temple destroyed? Because of baseless hatred (Sin'at Chinam).) A grudge is an instance of baseless hatred that can have devastating consequences for an individual and society.
    • The Talmud emphasizes "ואהבת לרעך כמוך" (love your neighbor as yourself) as a great principle in the Torah, with which grudge-holding is in complete contradiction.
  • הלכה (Halakha):

    • רמב"ם (Rambam - Maimonides), משנה תורה (Mishneh Torah), הלכות דעות (Hilchot De'ot - Laws of Ethical Character Traits) 7:8: Rambam explicitly addresses the prohibition against holding grudges, stating that a person should not harbor any hatred in their heart towards another. He even includes not holding a grudge over financial debts.
    • Rabbi חפץ חיים (Chafetz Chaim - Rabbi Yisrael Meir HaKohen), שמירת הלשון (Shmirat HaLashon - Guarding the Tongue): Although this book primarily deals with sins of speech, it emphasizes the importance of letting go of grudges and avoiding any negative feelings towards others that could lead to lashon hara or revenge.
    • שולחן ערוך (Shulchan Aruch), יורה דעה (Yoreh De'ah) 240: Deals with the laws related to "הלבנת פנים" (shaming another in public) and "הלכת מחילה" (laws of forgiveness), emphasizing the importance of forgiveness and not holding grudges.
  • מוסר (Mussar):

    • מסילת ישרים (Mesillat Yesharim): Ramchal, in chapters concerning "הנקיות" (Purity), "הפרישות" (Abstinence), and "אהבת ה'" (Love of HaShem), emphasizes the necessity of cleansing the heart from all negative feelings, including grudges. He considers a grudge a major obstacle to drawing near to HaShem and receiving His mercy.
    • חובות הלבבות (Chovot HaLevavot): Rabbi Bachya ibn Pakuda, in "שער חשבון הנפש" (Gate of Accounting of the Soul) and "שער התשובה" (Gate of Repentance), stresses the deep importance of self-examination to identify and uproot inner grudges and hatred. He explicitly states that a grudge hardens and darkens the heart.
    • "אורחות צדיקים" (Orchot Tzaddikim - Paths of the Righteous): This book has detailed chapters on "הכעס" (anger), "הקנאה" (envy), and "הנקמה" (revenge), all of which are related to holding a grudge. This book emphasizes the importance of "ביטול היש" (self-nullification/humility) and "שלום" (peace).
    • Rabbi ישראל סלנטר (Rabbi Yisrael Salanter): He viewed a grudge as a "מידה רעה" (bad trait) that secretly remains within a person and distances them from the spiritual path. He emphasized the necessity of continuous effort to discover and heal this hidden trait.

Common Examples of נְטִירַת הַקָּמָא Manifestations:

  • In Family Relationships:
    • Siblings who haven't spoken for years because one holds an old grudge over a childhood injustice or inheritance.
    • A child who harbors resentment towards their parents due to an unfair punishment or criticism in the past and has never been able to forgive them.
  • In the Workplace:
    • An employee who holds a grudge against their manager for not receiving a past promotion or being disrespected, and this grudge negatively impacts their performance and behavior at work.
    • Two colleagues who have been cold and indifferent to each other for years due to an old rivalry or past slander.
  • In Social Relationships:
    • Two old friends who have held a grudge due to a misunderstanding or something said years ago and no longer communicate.
    • An individual who harbors resentment towards a specific group due to a social injustice or unfairness, and this grudge affects their perspective and interactions with them.
  • In Financial Matters:
    • Someone who holds a grudge against another due to an old debt or an unfair transaction and is unwilling to forgive or compromise.

Ways to Overcome נְטִירַת הַקָּמָא:

Overcoming grudge-holding requires conscious, continuous, and deep effort towards תיקון המידות (Tikkun HaMiddot - rectification of character traits), cultivating שליטה עצמית (Shlitah Atzmit - self-control), אורך רוח (Orech Ruach - patience/longsuffering), עֲנָוָה (Anavah - humility), חֶמְלָה (Chemlah - compassion), and סליחה (Slichah - forgiveness).

  1. Understanding the Depth of the Sin and its Consequences:
    • Understanding its Root in Anger and Lack of Release: Deeply understand that holding a grudge is a sign of clinging to past anger and an inability to let go.
    • Reflecting on Harm to Soul and Body: Realize that a grudge is like a poison that not only contaminates your soul but can also lead to physical problems (such as stress, anxiety, high blood pressure).
    • Awareness of מצוות Violation and חִלּוּל הַשֵּׁם: Recognize that this act is a direct violation of a Torah commandment and a desecration of HaShem's Name.
    • Understanding that a Grudge Harms You: A grudge harms the person who holds it more than the person against whom it is held.
  2. Strengthening יראת שמים (Fear of HaShem), אֱמוּנָה (Faith), and וְבִטָּחוֹן (Trust):
    • HaShem's Presence and Divine Justice: Remind yourself that HaShem is just and will ultimately establish justice. You do not need to hold a grudge to "execute justice."
    • Emulating HaShem's Attributes: HaShem is "ארך אפים" (slow to anger) and "רב חסד" (abundant in kindness). We too should strive to cultivate these attributes as much as possible.
    • Trust (בִּטָּחוֹן): Trust in HaShem that He is in control of matters, and there is no need for worry or resentment.
    • Seeing Good in Difficulties: Try to seek a message from HaShem even in difficulties and harms, and use them for growth.
  3. Cultivating Positive Character Traits (תיקון המידות) and Practical Techniques:
    • Conscious Decision to Forgive (החלטה מודעת לסלוח): Forgiveness is an active decision, not an emotion. Even if you cannot change your feelings, you can decide to release the grudge.
    • Meditation and Self-Examination (התבוננות וחשבון נפש): Identify the roots of your grudge. What exactly bothers you? Does this grudge help you?
    • Expressing Emotions in a Healthy Way: Instead of suppressing anger, express it in a healthy way (e.g., by talking to a trusted friend, writing, or physical activity).
    • Changing the Narrative (שינוי הנרטיב): Instead of re-telling the story of your hurt with bitter details, try to transform it into a story of liberation and growth.
    • Practicing Empathy (אמפתיה): Try to understand the perspective of the person who harmed you. Were they suffering at the time? Did they act out of ignorance?
    • Praying for the Other Person (תפילה עבור האחר): Even if you cannot forgive them, pray for them. This act can soften your heart.
    • Practicing שלום (Peace): Instead of feeding the grudge, seek to create inner peace and peace with others.
    • "החזרת אבידה" (Returning a Lost Item): If someone owes you, even if it's not a financial debt, try to forgive them to "free" that person from the burden of sin.
    • Studying Mussar: Mussar texts specifically focus on cultivating forgiveness, humility, and avoiding anger and grudges.
  4. Seeking Support and Guidance:
    • Consulting a רב (Rabbi) or מורה דרך (Spiritual Mentor): They can help you gain a deeper understanding of Jewish teachings on grudges, forgiveness, and repentance.
    • תְּפִלָּה (Tefillah - Prayer): Ask HaShem for the strength to let go of grudges, forgive others, and cultivate a heart filled with peace and love.
    • Psychological Counseling: If your grudge is deep and chronic and seriously affects your life, seeking help from a psychologist or therapist is essential to work on forgiveness and managing negative emotions.

Through continuous practice of these strategies, with strong will, and by relying on HaShem, one can overcome the destructive trait of נְטִירַת הַקָּמָא (holding a grudge) and live a life based on peace, joy, forgiveness, healthy relationships, and a true connection with HaShem and others, which will benefit both the individual and society, materially and spiritually.

Revenge (Potentially Rooted in Anger)

נְקָמָה (Nekamah - Vengeance/Revenge): The Endless Cycle of Suffering

Revenge (נְקָמָה) refers to any act or intention to harm someone who has previously harmed you. This behavior is a violent, destructive, and dangerous manifestation of uncontrolled כַּעַס (Ka'as - anger/wrath) and deep שִׂנְאָה (Sin'ah - hatred). The vengeful individual, with the false belief that harming another can alleviate their own pain and suffering, enters a cycle of violence and bitterness. In Judaism, revenge is not only strongly condemned but explicitly prohibited in the Torah. This act stands in complete contradiction to the fundamental principles of "love your neighbor," mercy, and Divine justice.

Why is נְקָמָה problematic?

  1. Direct Violation of מצוות (Commandments): The Torah explicitly prohibits revenge.
  2. Rooted in Anger and Hatred: Revenge is born of anger and hatred, and rather than eliminating these emotions, it fuels them.
  3. Endless Cycle of Violence: Revenge perpetuates violence. Each act of revenge can become a reason for the next, creating an endless cycle.
  4. Destruction of Relationships and Society: Revenge destroys trust, obliterates peace and tranquility, and drives society towards chaos and enmity.
  5. Violation of Divine Justice: In Judaism, it is believed that ultimate justice belongs to HaShem. Taking revenge is, in essence, an attempt to usurp HaShem's right to execute justice.
  6. Obstacle to Repentance and Spiritual Growth: A vengeful person cannot fully repent or achieve spiritual growth because their heart is filled with anger and hatred.
  7. Self-Inflicted Harm: Revenge, more than anyone else, harms the vengeful individual themselves. It keeps them in constant pain, anxiety, and distress, preventing them from experiencing true peace and joy.
  8. חילול השם (Chilul HaShem - Desecration of HaShem's Name): Vengeful behavior by a religious person presents a very negative image of Judaism and can cause others to stray from HaShem's path.

Related Sources:

  • תורה (Torah):

    • ויקרא (Vayikra - Leviticus) 19:18: "לֹא תִקֹּם וְלֹא תִטֹּר אֶת בְּנֵי עַמֶּךָ וְאָהַבְתָּ לְרֵעֲךָ כָּמוֹךָ אֲנִי יְהוָה׃" ("Lo tikkom ve'lo tittor et benei ammecha ve'ahavta le're'acha kamocha Ani HaShem.") - "You shall not take vengeance or bear a grudge against the children of your people, but you shall love your neighbor as yourself. I am HaShem." This verse is the clearest and most direct prohibition against revenge (נקמה - Nekamah) in the Torah. The command "love your neighbor" is in complete contradiction to vengeance.
    • דברים (Devarim - Deuteronomy) 32:35: "לִי נָקָם וְשִׁלֵּם לְעֵת תָּמוּט רַגְלָם כִּי קָרוֹב יוֹם אֵידָם וְחָשׁ עֲתִידֹת לָמוֹ׃" ("Li nakam ve'shillem le'et tamut raglam ki karov yom eidam ve'chash atidot lamo.") - "Vengeance is Mine, and recompense, at the time their foot slips; for the day of their calamity is at hand, and their future hastens to them." This verse clearly states that vengeance is HaShem's exclusive right.
    • The Story of Joseph and His Brothers (בראשית - Bereishit): After years of suffering and separation, Joseph had the opportunity for revenge, but he treated his brothers with forgiveness and kindness and trusted in HaShem. This story is an inspiring example of the power of forgiveness and avoiding revenge.
  • תנ"ך (Tanakh - Nevi'im and Ketuvim):

    • משלי (Mishlei - Proverbs) 20:22: "אַל תֹּאמַר אֲשַׁלְּמָה רָע קַוֵּה לַיהוָה וְיֹשַׁע לָךְ׃" ("Al tomar ashallmah ra' kaveh la'HaShem ve'yosha lach.") - "Do not say, 'I will repay evil'; wait for HaShem, and He will save you." This verse clearly prohibits revenge and instead advises trust in HaShem.
    • Proverbs 24:29: "אַל תֹּאמַר כַּאֲשֶׁר עָשָׂה לִי כֵּן אֶעֱשֶׂה לּוֹ אָשִׁיב לָאִישׁ כְּפָעֳלוֹ׃" ("Al tomar ka'asher asah li ken e'eseh lo ashiv la'ish ke'fo'alo.") - "Do not say, 'As he has done to me, so I will do to him; I will render to the man according to his deed.'" This verse directly prohibits retaliation.
    • Psalms 7:5: "וְיִרְדֹּף אוֹיֵב נַפְשִׁי וְיַשִּׂג וְיִרְמֹס לָאָרֶץ חַיָּי וּכְבוֹדִי לֶעָפָר יַשְׁכֵּן סֶלָה׃" (May the enemy pursue my soul and overtake it; and may he trample my life to the ground and lay my glory in the dust. Selah.) This verse alludes to the destructive consequences of revenge.
    • Isaiah 59:18: "כְּעַל גְּמוּלוֹת כֵּן יְשַׁלֵּם חֵמָה לְצָרָיו גְּמוּל לְאֹיְבָיו לָאִיִּים גְּמוּל יְשַׁלֵּם׃" ("Ke'al gemulot ken yeshallem chemah le'tzarav gemul le'oyevav la'iyyim gemul yeshallem.") - "As [their] deeds deserve, so will He repay: fury to His adversaries, recompense to His enemies; to the islands He will repay recompense." This verse emphasizes the truth that ultimate vengeance belongs to HaShem.
  • מִשְׁנָה (Mishnah):

    • פרקי אבות (Pirkei Avot) 2:10: "כל הכועס – אם חכם הוא, חכמתו מסתלקת ממנו..." (Whoever becomes angry – if he is wise, his wisdom departs from him...) - Revenge is the epitome of folly stemming from anger.
    • פרקי אבות 4:1: "איזהו גיבור? הכובש את יצרו." (Who is mighty? One who conquers their Yetzer HaRa [evil inclination].) Overcoming the urge for revenge is a true sign of strength and heroism.
  • תַּלְמוּד (Talmud):

    • בבלי יומא (Bavli Yoma) 86b (regarding תְּשׁוּבָה): The Talmud states that sins between a person and their fellow (בין אדם לחברו) will not be forgiven until forgiveness is sought from the injured party. This shows that we must seek peace, not revenge.
    • בבלי ראש השנה (Bavli Rosh HaShanah) 17a: The Talmud emphasizes that if a person forgives another and does not take revenge, HaShem will also forgive them. This shows that forgiveness is a path to receiving Divine mercy.
    • בבלי שבת (Bavli Shabbat) 119a: "מפני מה חרב הבית השני? מפני שנאת חינם." (Why was the Second Temple destroyed? Because of baseless hatred (Sin'at Chinam).) Vengeance is one of the most prominent manifestations of baseless hatred.
    • The Talmud emphasizes the importance of "שלום" (peace) and "אהבת ישראל" (love for fellow Jews), which are in complete contradiction to revenge.
  • הלכה (Halakha):

    • רמב"ם (Rambam - Maimonides), משנה תורה (Mishneh Torah), הלכות דעות (Hilchot De'ot - Laws of Ethical Traits) 7:7-8: Rambam discusses in detail the prohibition of revenge and bearing a grudge. He explains how one must eradicate the desire for revenge even in one's heart. He gives an example: if someone asks you for something and you take revenge by saying, "I won't help you because you didn't help me yesterday," this is an act of revenge.
    • Rabbi חפץ חיים (Chafetz Chaim - Rabbi Yisrael Meir HaKohen), שמירת הלשון (Shmirat HaLashon - Guarding the Tongue): This book emphasizes the importance of avoiding revenge and any speech or action stemming from anger and hatred.
    • שולחן ערוך (Shulchan Aruch), חושן משפט (Choshen Mishpat): Although it covers laws related to causing harm and punishment, the emphasis is that such punishments must be carried out through the judicial system (Beit Din) and not through personal revenge.
  • מוסר (Mussar):

    • מסילת ישרים (Mesillat Yesharim): Ramchal, in the chapters concerning "הנקיות" (Purity), "הפרישות" (Abstinence), and "אהבת ה'" (Love of HaShem), emphasizes the necessity of purifying the heart from all negative emotions, including revenge. He considers revenge a great obstacle to spiritual growth and connection with HaShem.
    • חובות הלבבות (Chovot HaLevavot): Rabbi Bachya ibn Pakuda, in "שער הבטחון" (The Gate of Trust) and "שער התשובה" (The Gate of Repentance), emphasizes the importance of trusting HaShem to administer justice and releasing the desire for revenge. He considers grudges and revenge to be dangerous diseases of the soul.
    • "אורחות צדיקים" (Orchot Tzaddikim - Paths of the Righteous): This book has detailed chapters on "הנקמה" (revenge) and "הכעס" (anger) and addresses the destructive consequences of these traits. It emphasizes the importance of "סליחה" (forgiveness) and "שלום" (peace).
    • Rabbi ישראל סלנטר (Rabbi Yisrael Salanter): He viewed revenge as a "מידה רעה" (bad trait) that secretly remains within a person and distances them from their spiritual path. He emphasized the necessity of continuous effort to discover and heal this hidden trait.

Common Examples of נְקָמָה Manifestation:

  • Revenge in Family Relationships:
    • A spouse who, due to past infidelity, decides to take revenge on their partner through reciprocal infidelity or financial harm.
    • A sibling who, due to injustice in inheritance distribution, decides to cause financial or social harm to their sibling.
  • Revenge in the Workplace:
    • An employee who has been fired by their boss and decides to take revenge by sabotaging the system or leaking confidential information.
    • A colleague who missed out on a promotion and takes revenge by spreading rumors or damaging the reputation of another colleague.
  • Revenge in Social Relationships:
    • An individual who was insulted in a verbal dispute and later takes revenge by spreading private information or slander.
    • Tribal or blood feuds that continue for generations.
  • Cyber-revenge:
    • Releasing private photos or information of an individual online due to resentment or a failed relationship.

Ways to Overcome נְקָמָה:

Overcoming revenge requires conscious, continuous, and deep effort towards תיקון המידות (rectification of character traits), cultivating שליטה עצמית (Shlitah Atzmit - self-control), אורך רוח (Orech Ruach - patience/long-suffering), עֲנָוָה (Anavah - humility), חֶמְלָה (Chemlah - compassion), and most importantly, סליחה (Slichah - forgiveness) and בִּטָּחוֹן (Bitchon - trust in HaShem).

  1. Understanding the Depth of the Sin and Its Consequences:
    • Grasping the Violation of Divine Command: Deeply understand that revenge is a direct violation of HaShem's command.
    • Reflecting on Harm to the Soul and Lack of Peace: Understand that revenge is a poison that not only contaminates your soul but also prevents true peace and joy, keeping you in an endless cycle of suffering.
    • Awareness of חִלּוּל הַשֵּׁם and Idolatry: Recognize that this act devalues HaShem's name and religion and leads you to worship your own ego and anger.
    • Understanding Lack of Impact on the Other Person: Often, revenge causes less harm to the person you are taking revenge on than it does to yourself.
  2. Strengthening יראת שמים (Awe of HaShem), אֱמוּנָה (Faith), and וְבִטָּחוֹן (Trust in HaShem):
    • Belief in Divine Justice: Accept that HaShem is "בעל הגמולות" (the Master of Retribution) and that He will establish justice at the appropriate time.
    • Emulating HaShem's Attributes: HaShem is "ארך אפים" (slow to anger), "רב חסד" (abundant in kindness), and "מוחל עוונות" (forgiver of iniquities). We too must strive to cultivate these attributes within ourselves.
    • Trust (בִּטָּחוֹן): Trust in HaShem that He will orchestrate what is best for you, and that you do not need to administer personal justice.
  3. Cultivating Positive Character Traits (תיקון המידות) and Practical Techniques:
    • Forgiveness (סליחה):
      • Conscious Decision to Forgive: Forgiveness is an active decision, not an emotion. Even if you don't feel like forgiving, decide not to take revenge and to let go of grudges.
      • Separating the Person from the Act: You can condemn the act but forgive the person.
      • Forgiving for Your Own Sake: Forgiveness benefits you, not necessarily the other person. It's a way to release the heavy burden of anger and bitterness.
    • Anger Management (ניהול כעס): Identify the roots of your anger. Use techniques like deep breathing, leaving the situation, and relaxation.
    • Changing Thoughts (שינוי המחשבות): When the urge for revenge arises, consciously direct your thoughts towards positive things or towards HaShem's mercy and justice.
    • Empathy (אמפתיה): Try to understand the perspective of the person who harmed you. Were they in pain? Did they act out of ignorance?
    • Blessing the Other Person (ברכה לאחר): Even if it's difficult, wish well for the person who harmed you. This can soften your heart.
    • Focusing on Building, Not Destroying: Direct your energy toward creating positive things in your life and for others, rather than on destruction.
    • Rectification and Repentance (תיקון ותשובה): If you have harmed someone in the past due to revenge, humbly apologize and strive to repair the relationship.
    • Mussar Study: Mussar texts specifically focus on cultivating forgiveness, humility, patience, and avoiding anger and revenge.
  4. Seeking Support and Guidance:
    • Consulting with a רב (Rabbi) or מורה דרך (Spiritual Guide): They can help you deepen your understanding of Jewish teachings on revenge, forgiveness, and repentance.
    • תְּפִלָּה (Tefillah - Prayer): Ask HaShem for the strength to release the desire for revenge, to forgive others, and for a heart filled with peace and love.
    • Psychological Counseling: If the desire for revenge is deep and chronic and seriously impacts your life, seeking help from a psychologist or therapist to work on forgiveness, anger management, and coping with past emotional wounds is essential.

Through continuous practice of these strategies, with strong will, and by relying on HaShem, one can overcome the destructive trait of נְקָמָה (revenge) and live a life based on peace, joy, forgiveness, healthy relationships, and a true connection with HaShem and others, which will benefit both the individual and society, materially and spiritually.